Patient and Family Centered Actionable Processes of Care and Performance Measures for Persistent and Chronic Critical Illness: A Systematic Review. 2019

Louise Rose, and Laura Istanboulian, and Laura Allum, and Lisa Burry, and Craig Dale, and Nicholas Hart, and Kalliopi Kydonaki, and Pam Ramsay, and Natalie Pattison, and Bronwen Connolly

To identify actionable processes of care, quality indicators, or performance measures and their evidence base relevant to patients with persistent or chronic critical illness and their family members including themes relating to patient/family experience. METHODS Two authors independently searched electronic, systemic review, and trial registration databases (inception to November 2016). METHODS We included studies with an ICU length of stay of greater than or equal to 7 days as an inclusion criterion and reported actionable processes of care; quality improvement indicators, measures, or tools; or patient/family experience. We excluded case series/reports of less than 10 patients. METHODS Paired authors independently extracted data and performed risk of bias assessment. RESULTS We screened 13,130 references identifying 114 primary studies and 102 relevant reviews. Primary studies reported data on 24,252 participants; median (interquartile range) sample size of 70 (32-182). We identified 42 distinct actionable processes of care, the most commonly investigated related to categories of 1) weaning methods (21 studies; 27 reviews); 2) rehabilitation, mobilization, and physiotherapy (20 studies; 40 reviews); and 3) provision of information, prognosis, and family communication (14 studies; 11 reviews). Processes with limited evidence were generally more patient-centered categories such as communication, promotion of sleep, symptom management, or family support. Of the 21 randomized controlled trials, only two were considered at low risk of bias across all six domains, whereas just two cohort studies and one qualitative study were considered of high quality. CONCLUSIONS We identified 42 distinct actionable processes of care relevant to patients with persistent or chronic critical illness and their families, with most frequently studied processes relating to weaning, rehabilitation/mobilization, and family communication. Qualitative studies highlighted the need to address psychologic needs and distressing symptoms as well as enabling patient communication. Our findings are informative for clinicians and decision-makers when planning high-quality patient and family-focused care.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries

Related Publications

Louise Rose, and Laura Istanboulian, and Laura Allum, and Lisa Burry, and Craig Dale, and Nicholas Hart, and Kalliopi Kydonaki, and Pam Ramsay, and Natalie Pattison, and Bronwen Connolly
January 2023, Journal of research in medical sciences : the official journal of Isfahan University of Medical Sciences,
Louise Rose, and Laura Istanboulian, and Laura Allum, and Lisa Burry, and Craig Dale, and Nicholas Hart, and Kalliopi Kydonaki, and Pam Ramsay, and Natalie Pattison, and Bronwen Connolly
June 2024, Pediatric research,
Louise Rose, and Laura Istanboulian, and Laura Allum, and Lisa Burry, and Craig Dale, and Nicholas Hart, and Kalliopi Kydonaki, and Pam Ramsay, and Natalie Pattison, and Bronwen Connolly
June 2023, Nursing open,
Louise Rose, and Laura Istanboulian, and Laura Allum, and Lisa Burry, and Craig Dale, and Nicholas Hart, and Kalliopi Kydonaki, and Pam Ramsay, and Natalie Pattison, and Bronwen Connolly
April 2012, Western journal of nursing research,
Louise Rose, and Laura Istanboulian, and Laura Allum, and Lisa Burry, and Craig Dale, and Nicholas Hart, and Kalliopi Kydonaki, and Pam Ramsay, and Natalie Pattison, and Bronwen Connolly
February 1995, Nebraska nurse,
Louise Rose, and Laura Istanboulian, and Laura Allum, and Lisa Burry, and Craig Dale, and Nicholas Hart, and Kalliopi Kydonaki, and Pam Ramsay, and Natalie Pattison, and Bronwen Connolly
January 2008, Journal of general internal medicine,
Louise Rose, and Laura Istanboulian, and Laura Allum, and Lisa Burry, and Craig Dale, and Nicholas Hart, and Kalliopi Kydonaki, and Pam Ramsay, and Natalie Pattison, and Bronwen Connolly
January 2021, MDM policy & practice,
Louise Rose, and Laura Istanboulian, and Laura Allum, and Lisa Burry, and Craig Dale, and Nicholas Hart, and Kalliopi Kydonaki, and Pam Ramsay, and Natalie Pattison, and Bronwen Connolly
January 2011, Annals of family medicine,
Louise Rose, and Laura Istanboulian, and Laura Allum, and Lisa Burry, and Craig Dale, and Nicholas Hart, and Kalliopi Kydonaki, and Pam Ramsay, and Natalie Pattison, and Bronwen Connolly
January 2000, Health technology assessment (Winchester, England),
Louise Rose, and Laura Istanboulian, and Laura Allum, and Lisa Burry, and Craig Dale, and Nicholas Hart, and Kalliopi Kydonaki, and Pam Ramsay, and Natalie Pattison, and Bronwen Connolly
November 2018, International journal of nursing studies,
Copied contents to your clipboard!