Left Ventricular End Diastolic Volume and Ejection Fraction Calculation: Correlation between Three Echocardiographic Methods. 2020

Nadia Benyounes, and Clélie Van Der Vynckt, and Thierry Tibi, and Alexandra Iglesias, and Olivier Gout, and Sylvie Lang, and Laurence Salomon
Cardiology Unit, A. de Rothschild Foundation, Paris, France.

BACKGROUND Left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF) and end diastolic volume (EDV) are measured using Simpson's biplane (SB), 3-dimensional method (3DE), and speckle tracking (STE). Comparisons between methods in routine practice are limited. Our purpose was to compare and to determine the correlations between these three methods in clinical setting. METHODS LVEF and EDV were measured by three methods in 474 consecutive patients and compared using multiple Bland-Altman (BA) plots. The correlations (R) between methods were calculated. RESULTS Median (IQR) LVEF_SB, LVEF_STE, and LVEF_3DE were 63.0% (60-69)%, 61% (57-65)%, and 62% (57-68)%. Median (IQR) EDV_SB, EDV_STE, and EDV_3DE were 85 ml (71-106) ml, 82 ml (69-100) ml, and 73 ml (59-89) ml. R between LVEF_SB and LVEF_3DE was 0.65 when echogenicity was good and 0.43 when poor. R for EDV_SB and EDV_3DE was 0.75 when echogenicity was good and 0.45 when poor. On BA analysis, biases were acceptable (<3.5% for LVEF) but limits of agreement (LOA) were large: 95% of the differences were between -15.4% and +18.8% for LVEF as evaluated by SB in comparison with 3DE, with a bias of 1.7%. In the comparison EDV_SB and EDV_3DE, the bias was 14 ml and the LOA were between -24 ml and +53 ml. On linear regressions, LVEF_3DE = 17.92 + 0.69 LVEF_SB and EDV_3DE = 18.94 + 0.63 EDV_SB. CONCLUSIONS The three methods were feasible and led to acceptable bias but large LOA. Although these methods are not interchangeable, our results allow 3DE value prediction from SB, the most commonly used method.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries

Related Publications

Nadia Benyounes, and Clélie Van Der Vynckt, and Thierry Tibi, and Alexandra Iglesias, and Olivier Gout, and Sylvie Lang, and Laurence Salomon
January 2013, Congestive heart failure (Greenwich, Conn.),
Nadia Benyounes, and Clélie Van Der Vynckt, and Thierry Tibi, and Alexandra Iglesias, and Olivier Gout, and Sylvie Lang, and Laurence Salomon
January 2002, ASAIO journal (American Society for Artificial Internal Organs : 1992),
Nadia Benyounes, and Clélie Van Der Vynckt, and Thierry Tibi, and Alexandra Iglesias, and Olivier Gout, and Sylvie Lang, and Laurence Salomon
May 1985, American heart journal,
Nadia Benyounes, and Clélie Van Der Vynckt, and Thierry Tibi, and Alexandra Iglesias, and Olivier Gout, and Sylvie Lang, and Laurence Salomon
November 1998, Echocardiography (Mount Kisco, N.Y.),
Nadia Benyounes, and Clélie Van Der Vynckt, and Thierry Tibi, and Alexandra Iglesias, and Olivier Gout, and Sylvie Lang, and Laurence Salomon
July 2002, The Journal of surgical research,
Nadia Benyounes, and Clélie Van Der Vynckt, and Thierry Tibi, and Alexandra Iglesias, and Olivier Gout, and Sylvie Lang, and Laurence Salomon
November 1981, [Zasshi] [Journal]. Nihon Kyobu Geka Gakkai,
Nadia Benyounes, and Clélie Van Der Vynckt, and Thierry Tibi, and Alexandra Iglesias, and Olivier Gout, and Sylvie Lang, and Laurence Salomon
September 2020, The international journal of cardiovascular imaging,
Nadia Benyounes, and Clélie Van Der Vynckt, and Thierry Tibi, and Alexandra Iglesias, and Olivier Gout, and Sylvie Lang, and Laurence Salomon
May 2018, Clinical cardiology,
Nadia Benyounes, and Clélie Van Der Vynckt, and Thierry Tibi, and Alexandra Iglesias, and Olivier Gout, and Sylvie Lang, and Laurence Salomon
October 1986, Methods and findings in experimental and clinical pharmacology,
Nadia Benyounes, and Clélie Van Der Vynckt, and Thierry Tibi, and Alexandra Iglesias, and Olivier Gout, and Sylvie Lang, and Laurence Salomon
June 1988, Journal of nuclear medicine : official publication, Society of Nuclear Medicine,
Copied contents to your clipboard!