Aortic stenosis may be complicated by an acquired von Willebrand syndrome that rarely causes significant bleeding, raising the question of why it does so in a few cases. To seek an explanation, we studied 5 severe bleeder aortic stenosis patients in a cohort of 49 patients, using the flowchart for inherited von Willebrand disease. Approach and Results: All 5 patients were lacking in large and intermediate VWF (von Willebrand factor) multimers, 3 had reduced plasma and platelet VWF levels, and none showed PFA100 closure. Two patients (those with most multimers missing) also had a short VWF half-life. Genetic analyses on the 3 patients with reduced platelet VWF levels revealed that one carried both the c.1164C>G and the c.7880G>A mutations, and another carried the c.3390C>T mutation, while the third had one of the 2 VWF alleles relatively less expressed than the other (25% versus 75%). No genetic alterations emerged in the other 2 patients. Successful replacement of the stenotic aortic valve, performed in the 2 patients with VWF mutations, did not correct their abnormal VWF multimer picture-unlike what happened in the aortic stenosis patients without bleeding symptoms. Our findings suggest that acquired von Willebrand syndrome can develop in patients with hitherto-undiagnosed inherited von Willebrand disease. Since von Willebrand disease is the most common bleeding disorder, this possibility should be considered in aortic stenosis patients-especially those with a more severe bleeding history and more disrupted VWF laboratory patterns-because they risk hemorrhage during aortic valve replacement.