Modes of exercise training for intermittent claudication. 2020

Sandra Cp Jansen, and Ukachukwu Okoroafor Abaraogu, and Gert Jan Lauret, and Farzin Fakhry, and Hugo Jp Fokkenrood, and Joep Aw Teijink
Department of Vascular Surgery, Catharina Hospital, Eindhoven, Netherlands.

According to international guidelines and literature, all patients with intermittent claudication should receive an initial treatment of cardiovascular risk modification, lifestyle coaching, and supervised exercise therapy. In the literature, supervised exercise therapy often consists of treadmill or track walking. However, alternative modes of exercise therapy have been described and yielded similar results to walking. This raises the following question: which exercise mode produces the most favourable results? This is the first update of the original review published in 2014. To assess the effects of alternative modes of supervised exercise therapy compared to traditional walking exercise in patients with intermittent claudication. The Cochrane Vascular Information Specialist searched the Cochrane Vascular Specialised Register, CENTRAL, MEDLINE, Embase and CINAHL databases and World Health Organization International Clinical Trials Registry Platform and ClinicalTrials.gov trials registers to 4 March 2019. We also undertook reference checking, citation searching and contact with study authors to identify additional studies. No language restriction was applied. We included parallel-group randomised controlled trials comparing alternative modes of exercise training or combinations of exercise modes with a control group of supervised walking exercise in patients with clinically determined intermittent claudication. The supervised walking programme needed to be supervised at least twice a week for a consecutive six weeks of training. Two review authors independently selected studies, extracted data, and assessed the risk of bias for each study. As we included studies with different treadmill test protocols and different measuring units (metres, minutes, or seconds), the standardised mean difference (SMD) approach was used for summary statistics of mean walking distance (MWD) and pain-free walking distance (PFWD). Summary estimates were obtained for all outcome measures using a random-effects model. We used the GRADE approach to assess the certainty of the evidence. For this update, five additional studies were included, making a total of 10 studies that randomised a total of 527 participants with intermittent claudication (IC). The alternative modes of exercise therapy included cycling, lower-extremity resistance training, upper-arm ergometry, Nordic walking, and combinations of exercise modes. Besides randomised controlled trials, two quasi-randomised trials were included. Overall risk of bias in included studies varied from high to low. According to GRADE criteria, the certainty of the evidence was downgraded to low, due to the relatively small sample sizes, clinical inconsistency, and inclusion of three studies with risk of bias concerns. Overall, comparing alternative exercise modes versus walking showed no clear differences for MWD at 12 weeks (standardised mean difference (SMD) -0.01, 95% confidence interval (CI) -0.29 to 0.27; P = 0.95; 6 studies; 274 participants; low-certainty evidence); or at the end of training (SMD -0.11, 95% CI -0.33 to 0.11; P = 0.32; 9 studies; 412 participants; low-certainty evidence). Similarly, no clear differences were detected in PFWD at 12 weeks (SMD -0.01, 95% CI -0.26 to 0.25; P = 0.97; 5 studies; 249 participants; low-certainty evidence); or at the end of training (SMD -0.06, 95% CI -0.30 to 0.17; P = 0.59; 8 studies, 382 participants; low-certainty evidence). Four studies reported on health-related quality of life (HR-QoL) and three studies reported on functional impairment. As the studies used different measurements, meta-analysis was only possible for the walking impairment questionnaire (WIQ) distance score, which demonstrated little or no difference between groups (MD -5.52, 95% CI -17.41 to 6.36; P = 0.36; 2 studies; 96 participants; low-certainty evidence). This review found no clear difference between alternative exercise modes and supervised walking exercise in improving the maximum and pain-free walking distance in patients with intermittent claudication. The certainty of this evidence was judged to be low, due to clinical inconsistency, small sample size and risk of bias concerns. The findings of this review indicate that alternative exercise modes may be useful when supervised walking exercise is not an option. More RCTs with adequate methodological quality and sufficient power are needed to provide solid evidence for comparisons between each alternative exercise mode and the current standard of supervised treadmill walking. Future RCTs should investigate outcome measures on walking behaviour, physical activity, cardiovascular risk, and HR-QoL, using standardised testing methods and reporting of outcomes to allow meaningful comparison across studies.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D007383 Intermittent Claudication A symptom complex characterized by pain and weakness in SKELETAL MUSCLE group associated with exercise, such as leg pain and weakness brought on by walking. Such muscle limpness disappears after a brief rest and is often relates to arterial STENOSIS; muscle ISCHEMIA; and accumulation of LACTATE. Claudication, Intermittent
D002318 Cardiovascular Diseases Pathological conditions involving the CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM including the HEART; the BLOOD VESSELS; or the PERICARDIUM. Adverse Cardiac Event,Cardiac Events,Major Adverse Cardiac Events,Adverse Cardiac Events,Cardiac Event,Cardiac Event, Adverse,Cardiac Events, Adverse,Cardiovascular Disease,Disease, Cardiovascular,Event, Cardiac
D005080 Exercise Test Controlled physical activity which is performed in order to allow assessment of physiological functions, particularly cardiovascular and pulmonary, but also aerobic capacity. Maximal (most intense) exercise is usually required but submaximal exercise is also used. Arm Ergometry Test,Bicycle Ergometry Test,Cardiopulmonary Exercise Testing,Exercise Testing,Step Test,Stress Test,Treadmill Test,Cardiopulmonary Exercise Test,EuroFit Tests,Eurofit Test Battery,European Fitness Testing Battery,Fitness Testing,Physical Fitness Testing,Arm Ergometry Tests,Bicycle Ergometry Tests,Cardiopulmonary Exercise Tests,Ergometry Test, Arm,Ergometry Test, Bicycle,Ergometry Tests, Arm,Ergometry Tests, Bicycle,EuroFit Test,Eurofit Test Batteries,Exercise Test, Cardiopulmonary,Exercise Testing, Cardiopulmonary,Exercise Tests,Exercise Tests, Cardiopulmonary,Fitness Testing, Physical,Fitness Testings,Step Tests,Stress Tests,Test Battery, Eurofit,Test, Arm Ergometry,Test, Bicycle Ergometry,Test, Cardiopulmonary Exercise,Test, EuroFit,Test, Exercise,Test, Step,Test, Stress,Test, Treadmill,Testing, Cardiopulmonary Exercise,Testing, Exercise,Testing, Fitness,Testing, Physical Fitness,Tests, Arm Ergometry,Tests, Bicycle Ergometry,Tests, Cardiopulmonary Exercise,Tests, EuroFit,Tests, Exercise,Tests, Step,Tests, Stress,Tests, Treadmill,Treadmill Tests
D005081 Exercise Therapy A regimen or plan of physical activities designed and prescribed for specific therapeutic goals. Its purpose is to restore normal musculoskeletal function or to reduce pain caused by diseases or injuries. Rehabilitation Exercise,Remedial Exercise,Therapy, Exercise,Exercise Therapies,Exercise, Rehabilitation,Exercise, Remedial,Exercises, Rehabilitation,Exercises, Remedial,Rehabilitation Exercises,Remedial Exercises,Therapies, Exercise
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000070857 Walk Test A measure of endurance tests that show how far and fast an individual can walk without stopping within a certain period of time. 6-Min Walk Test,Six-Minute Walk Test,6-Minute Walk Test,Endurance Shuttle Walk Test,Incremental Shuttle Walk Test,6 Min Walk Test,6 Minute Walk Test,6-Min Walk Tests,6-Minute Walk Tests,Six Minute Walk Test,Six-Minute Walk Tests,Test, 6-Min Walk,Test, 6-Minute Walk,Test, Six-Minute Walk,Test, Walk,Tests, 6-Min Walk,Tests, 6-Minute Walk,Tests, Six-Minute Walk,Tests, Walk,Walk Test, 6-Min,Walk Test, 6-Minute,Walk Test, Six-Minute,Walk Tests,Walk Tests, 6-Min,Walk Tests, 6-Minute,Walk Tests, Six-Minute
D000328 Adult A person having attained full growth or maturity. Adults are of 19 through 44 years of age. For a person between 19 and 24 years of age, YOUNG ADULT is available. Adults
D001642 Bicycling The use of a bicycle for transportation or recreation. It does not include the use of a bicycle in studying the body's response to physical exertion (BICYCLE ERGOMETRY TEST see EXERCISE TEST).
D012865 Skiing A snow sport which uses skis to glide over the snow. It does not include water-skiing. Snowboarding,Snow Skiing,Skiing, Snow,Skiings, Snow,Snow Skiings
D015982 Bias Any deviation of results or inferences from the truth, or processes leading to such deviation. Bias can result from several sources: one-sided or systematic variations in measurement from the true value (systematic error); flaws in study design; deviation of inferences, interpretations, or analyses based on flawed data or data collection; etc. There is no sense of prejudice or subjectivity implied in the assessment of bias under these conditions. Aggregation Bias,Bias, Aggregation,Bias, Ecological,Bias, Statistical,Bias, Systematic,Ecological Bias,Outcome Measurement Errors,Statistical Bias,Systematic Bias,Bias, Epidemiologic,Biases,Biases, Ecological,Biases, Statistical,Ecological Biases,Ecological Fallacies,Ecological Fallacy,Epidemiologic Biases,Experimental Bias,Fallacies, Ecological,Fallacy, Ecological,Scientific Bias,Statistical Biases,Truncation Bias,Truncation Biases,Bias, Experimental,Bias, Scientific,Bias, Truncation,Biase, Epidemiologic,Biases, Epidemiologic,Biases, Truncation,Epidemiologic Biase,Error, Outcome Measurement,Errors, Outcome Measurement,Outcome Measurement Error

Related Publications

Sandra Cp Jansen, and Ukachukwu Okoroafor Abaraogu, and Gert Jan Lauret, and Farzin Fakhry, and Hugo Jp Fokkenrood, and Joep Aw Teijink
July 2014, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews,
Sandra Cp Jansen, and Ukachukwu Okoroafor Abaraogu, and Gert Jan Lauret, and Farzin Fakhry, and Hugo Jp Fokkenrood, and Joep Aw Teijink
November 2017, Journal of vascular surgery,
Sandra Cp Jansen, and Ukachukwu Okoroafor Abaraogu, and Gert Jan Lauret, and Farzin Fakhry, and Hugo Jp Fokkenrood, and Joep Aw Teijink
February 2018, Journal of vascular surgery,
Sandra Cp Jansen, and Ukachukwu Okoroafor Abaraogu, and Gert Jan Lauret, and Farzin Fakhry, and Hugo Jp Fokkenrood, and Joep Aw Teijink
March 2000, International angiology : a journal of the International Union of Angiology,
Sandra Cp Jansen, and Ukachukwu Okoroafor Abaraogu, and Gert Jan Lauret, and Farzin Fakhry, and Hugo Jp Fokkenrood, and Joep Aw Teijink
January 1983, Scandinavian journal of rehabilitation medicine. Supplement,
Sandra Cp Jansen, and Ukachukwu Okoroafor Abaraogu, and Gert Jan Lauret, and Farzin Fakhry, and Hugo Jp Fokkenrood, and Joep Aw Teijink
October 2008, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews,
Sandra Cp Jansen, and Ukachukwu Okoroafor Abaraogu, and Gert Jan Lauret, and Farzin Fakhry, and Hugo Jp Fokkenrood, and Joep Aw Teijink
May 1969, Drug and therapeutics bulletin,
Sandra Cp Jansen, and Ukachukwu Okoroafor Abaraogu, and Gert Jan Lauret, and Farzin Fakhry, and Hugo Jp Fokkenrood, and Joep Aw Teijink
July 2011, Physical therapy,
Sandra Cp Jansen, and Ukachukwu Okoroafor Abaraogu, and Gert Jan Lauret, and Farzin Fakhry, and Hugo Jp Fokkenrood, and Joep Aw Teijink
January 2000, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews,
Sandra Cp Jansen, and Ukachukwu Okoroafor Abaraogu, and Gert Jan Lauret, and Farzin Fakhry, and Hugo Jp Fokkenrood, and Joep Aw Teijink
December 2017, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews,
Copied contents to your clipboard!