Sickle erythrocytes are known to undergo excessive auto-oxidation, resulting in the generation of increased intracellular levels of several species of free radical oxidants. This environment is likely to enhance the accumulation of oxidative lesions by membrane components, although, as yet, this has been shown directly only for the sickle membrane phospholipids. We examined the oxidative status of protein 4.1, a major component of the human erythrocyte protein skeleton. We found that protein 4.1 isolated from sickle erythrocytes bound approximately 4-fold less to protein 4.1-stripped membranes than did the normal protein. The binding defect was inherent in the sickle protein and not in its membrane-binding site(s) since normal protein 4.1 bound to sickle protein 4.1-stripped inside-out vesicles similar to normal protein 4.1-stripped inside-out vesicles. Sickle membranes, in particular spectrin-depleted inside-out vesicles, contained less protein 4.1 than normal membranes. Purified sickle protein 4.1 contained 20-40% high molecular weight aggregated protein (Mr greater than 200,000), whereas the purified normal protein contained approximately 10% high molecular weight protein. The high molecular weight protein was immunoreactive with antibodies to protein 4.1 but not with antibodies to spectrin, ankyrin, band 3, glycophorin, or hemoglobin, suggesting that the high molecular weight protein was cross-linked protein 4.1 and not a complex of protein 4.1 and some other membrane protein(s). Purified sickle protein 4.1 was eluted from an anion-exchange resin at a higher salt concentration than normal protein 4.1. Oxidizing normal protein 4.1 with diamide resulted in an anion-exchange elution pattern similar to the sickle protein, suggesting that oxidation can affect protein surface charge. Activated thiol beads bound one-half as much sickle protein 4.1 as normal protein 4.1 when both were solubilized directly from membranes, demonstrating that thiol oxidation had occurred in vivo. Direct quantification of protein thiols revealed that the sickle protein contained 1-2 mol% fewer cysteines/protein 4.1 monomer than did the normal protein. By amino acid analysis, sickle protein 4.1 was found to contain less methionine and tyrosine than did the normal protein and contained approximately 1 mol% cysteic acid, whereas the normal protein did not contain any cysteic acid. Taken together, our results strongly suggest that sickle protein 4.1 has sustained oxidative damage in vivo. This damage can alter the functional properties of the sickle protein and may be an underlying factor in the myriad of membrane abnormalities reported in sickle erythrocytes.