There is an urgent need for a peripheral nerve repair product that can match or exceed the abilities of the current "gold-standard", nerve autografts. Using a sectioning-based fabrication technique, decellularized tendon sections formed into tubular conduits that maintain the native structure of the collagen. Our previous studies have demonstrated that these collagen structures provide nanotopographical growth guidance cues for regenerating neurons and support glia. Here, the regenerative abilities of the tendon-derived nerve guidance conduits to repair a critically sized defect (15 mm) are evaluated in a rat sciatic nerve model. Using the conduits, functional recovery occurs at a similar rate to isografts, when evaluated with a sciatic function index test. However, muscular recovery, as measured by gastrocnemius weight, was not as great in the conduit-treated group. Both conduit and isograft repairs are histologically evaluated using Masson's trichrome stain and immunofluorescent staining for neurofilament-160 and S100 (markers for neurons and Schwann cells, respectively). This evaluation shows that by week 14, conduits promote regrowth of both neuronal tissue and some physiological support structures, such as blood vessels and epi/perineurium-like structures. Lastly, positive staining for these two markers at week 14 is calculated as a quantitative means of assessment, and shows greater total content of neurofilament-160 and S100 in conduits than in isografts, but a smaller percent area, which may be a result of the greater cross-sectional area of the conduit.