High-temperature stress severely impacts both yield and quality of tomato fruits, and therefore, it is required to develop stress-tolerant cultivars. In the present study, two tomato genotypes, H88-78-1 and CLN-1621, identified through preliminary phenotypic screening were characterized by analysis of molecular, physiological, and biochemical traits in comparison with a susceptible genotype Punjab Chhuhara. Phenotypic stress tolerance of both the genotypes was validated at biochemical level as they showed higher amount of relative water content, photosynthetic pigments, free cellular proline, and antioxidant molecules while less amount of H2O2 and electrolyte leakage. Expression analysis of 67 genes including heat shock factors, heat shock proteins, and other stress-responsive genes showed significant up-regulation of many of the genes such as 17.4 kDa class III heat shock protein, HSF A-4a, HSF30, HSF B-2a, HSF24, HSF B-3 like, 18.1 kDa class I HSP like, and HSP17.4 in H88-78-1 and CLN-1621 after exposure to high-temperature stress. These candidate genes can be transferred to cultivated varieties by developing gene-based markers and marker-assisted breeding. This confirms the rapid response of these genotypes to high-temperature stress. All these traits are characteristics of a stress-tolerance and establish them as candidate high-temperature stress-tolerant genotypes that can be effectively utilized in stress tolerance improvement programs. BACKGROUND The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s13205-020-02587-6.