Comparison of Efficacy of Povidone-Iodine, Ethanol, and an Aerosol Formulation of Silver Sulfadiazine in Controlling Microbial Burden on Sutures From Clean Surgeries. 2021

Gustavo E Prezzavento, and Carlos R Mas, and Juan Achaval Rodríguez, and Rodrigo N Juárez Calvi, and Laura Piskulic, and Julia Angelini, and María B Allasia, and Andrea M Smania, and Alejandro J Moyano
Servicio Cirugía Plástica y Reconstructiva, Hospital Alemán, Buenos Aires, Argentina.

In the surgical suture, the implanted thread can be a source of microbial contamination. Implanted materials are frequently described as being substrates prone for biofilm development provoking surgical site infections. Treatment of postsurgical wounds with different topical antimicrobial agents is a current practice applied to every patient. However, to date, there is little evidence on the efficacy of different antiseptic treatments on suture materials in preventing environmental or skin bacterial adhesion and further infection. Here, the authors compared the ability of an aerosol formulation of silver sulfadiazine, vitamin A, and lidocaine (AF-SSD) and of two of the most frequently used topical treatments, povidone-iodine and ethanol, in eradicating or controlling the microbial contamination of suture threads in patients who have undergone clean surgeries. Postsurgical suture threads treated with AF-SSD showed a significantly reduced proportion of contaminated samples containing viable microbial cells compared with those treated with povidone-iodine or ethanol. Furthermore, those samples that were positive for bacterial growth showed a lesser number of viable cells in AF-SSD-treated sutures than those treated with povidone-iodine or ethanol. Confocal laser scanning microscopy showed that AF-SSD-treated postsurgical sutures presented significantly less attached microbial cells than povidone-iodine and ethanol, with scarce observable microbial cells on the surface of the suture. Taken together, the results suggest that treatment with AF-SSD is more effective than the other two antiseptics, and there is a potential for improvement in reducing the microbial burden of implanted materials such as the suture thread.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D011206 Povidone-Iodine An iodinated polyvinyl polymer used as topical antiseptic in surgery and for skin and mucous membrane infections, also as aerosol. The iodine may be radiolabeled for research purposes. PVP-Iodine,Polyvinylpyrrolidone Iodine,Alphadine,Betadine,Betaisodona,Disadine,Isodine,PVP-I,Pharmadine,Providine,Alphadines,Betadines,Disadines,Isodines,PVP Iodine,PVP-Iodines,Pharmadines,Polyvinylpyrrolidone Iodines,Povidone Iodine,Povidone-Iodines,Providines
D002056 Burns Injuries to tissues caused by contact with heat, steam, chemicals (BURNS, CHEMICAL), electricity (BURNS, ELECTRIC), or the like. Burn
D005500 Follow-Up Studies Studies in which individuals or populations are followed to assess the outcome of exposures, procedures, or effects of a characteristic, e.g., occurrence of disease. Followup Studies,Follow Up Studies,Follow-Up Study,Followup Study,Studies, Follow-Up,Studies, Followup,Study, Follow-Up,Study, Followup
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000287 Administration, Topical The application of drug preparations to the surfaces of the body, especially the skin (ADMINISTRATION, CUTANEOUS) or mucous membranes. This method of treatment is used to avoid systemic side effects when high doses are required at a localized area or as an alternative systemic administration route, to avoid hepatic processing for example. Drug Administration, Topical,Administration, Topical Drug,Topical Administration,Topical Drug Administration,Administrations, Topical,Administrations, Topical Drug,Drug Administrations, Topical,Topical Administrations,Topical Drug Administrations
D000336 Aerosols Colloids with a gaseous dispersing phase and either liquid (fog) or solid (smoke) dispersed phase; used in fumigation or in inhalation therapy; may contain propellant agents. Aerosol
D000431 Ethanol A clear, colorless liquid rapidly absorbed from the gastrointestinal tract and distributed throughout the body. It has bactericidal activity and is used often as a topical disinfectant. It is widely used as a solvent and preservative in pharmaceutical preparations as well as serving as the primary ingredient in ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES. Alcohol, Ethyl,Absolute Alcohol,Grain Alcohol,Alcohol, Absolute,Alcohol, Grain,Ethyl Alcohol
D000891 Anti-Infective Agents, Local Substances used on humans and other animals that destroy harmful microorganisms or inhibit their activity. They are distinguished from DISINFECTANTS, which are used on inanimate objects. Anti-Infective Agents, Topical,Antiseptic,Antiseptics,Microbicides, Local,Microbicides, Topical,Antiinfective Agents, Local,Antiinfective Agents, Topical,Local Anti-Infective Agents,Local Antiinfective Agents,Topical Anti-Infective Agents,Topical Antiinfective Agents,Agents, Local Anti-Infective,Agents, Local Antiinfective,Agents, Topical Anti-Infective,Agents, Topical Antiinfective,Anti Infective Agents, Local,Anti Infective Agents, Topical,Local Anti Infective Agents,Local Microbicides,Topical Anti Infective Agents,Topical Microbicides
D012837 Silver Sulfadiazine Antibacterial used topically in burn therapy. Brandiazin,Dermazin,Flamazine,Flammazine,SSD,SSD AF,Sicazine,Silvadene,Silvederma,Sulfafdiazine, Silver,Sulfargen,Thermazene,Silver Sulfafdiazine,Sulfadiazine, Silver
D013530 Surgical Wound Infection Infection occurring at the site of a surgical incision. Postoperative Wound Infection,Infection, Postoperative Wound,Infection, Surgical Wound,Surgical Site Infection,Wound Infection, Postoperative,Wound Infection, Surgical,Infection, Surgical Site,Infections, Postoperative Wound,Infections, Surgical Site,Infections, Surgical Wound,Postoperative Wound Infections,Surgical Site Infections,Surgical Wound Infections,Wound Infections, Postoperative,Wound Infections, Surgical

Related Publications

Gustavo E Prezzavento, and Carlos R Mas, and Juan Achaval Rodríguez, and Rodrigo N Juárez Calvi, and Laura Piskulic, and Julia Angelini, and María B Allasia, and Andrea M Smania, and Alejandro J Moyano
January 2006, Dermatology (Basel, Switzerland),
Gustavo E Prezzavento, and Carlos R Mas, and Juan Achaval Rodríguez, and Rodrigo N Juárez Calvi, and Laura Piskulic, and Julia Angelini, and María B Allasia, and Andrea M Smania, and Alejandro J Moyano
January 2010, Chemotherapy,
Gustavo E Prezzavento, and Carlos R Mas, and Juan Achaval Rodríguez, and Rodrigo N Juárez Calvi, and Laura Piskulic, and Julia Angelini, and María B Allasia, and Andrea M Smania, and Alejandro J Moyano
November 1977, JACEP,
Gustavo E Prezzavento, and Carlos R Mas, and Juan Achaval Rodríguez, and Rodrigo N Juárez Calvi, and Laura Piskulic, and Julia Angelini, and María B Allasia, and Andrea M Smania, and Alejandro J Moyano
May 1981, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society,
Gustavo E Prezzavento, and Carlos R Mas, and Juan Achaval Rodríguez, and Rodrigo N Juárez Calvi, and Laura Piskulic, and Julia Angelini, and María B Allasia, and Andrea M Smania, and Alejandro J Moyano
January 1984, Infection,
Gustavo E Prezzavento, and Carlos R Mas, and Juan Achaval Rodríguez, and Rodrigo N Juárez Calvi, and Laura Piskulic, and Julia Angelini, and María B Allasia, and Andrea M Smania, and Alejandro J Moyano
January 2014, Plastic surgery international,
Gustavo E Prezzavento, and Carlos R Mas, and Juan Achaval Rodríguez, and Rodrigo N Juárez Calvi, and Laura Piskulic, and Julia Angelini, and María B Allasia, and Andrea M Smania, and Alejandro J Moyano
November 2015, Surgery today,
Gustavo E Prezzavento, and Carlos R Mas, and Juan Achaval Rodríguez, and Rodrigo N Juárez Calvi, and Laura Piskulic, and Julia Angelini, and María B Allasia, and Andrea M Smania, and Alejandro J Moyano
July 2023, Retina (Philadelphia, Pa.),
Gustavo E Prezzavento, and Carlos R Mas, and Juan Achaval Rodríguez, and Rodrigo N Juárez Calvi, and Laura Piskulic, and Julia Angelini, and María B Allasia, and Andrea M Smania, and Alejandro J Moyano
January 2022, Frontiers in microbiology,
Gustavo E Prezzavento, and Carlos R Mas, and Juan Achaval Rodríguez, and Rodrigo N Juárez Calvi, and Laura Piskulic, and Julia Angelini, and María B Allasia, and Andrea M Smania, and Alejandro J Moyano
July 2011, Annals of maxillofacial surgery,
Copied contents to your clipboard!