Comparison of Language and Memory Lateralization by Functional MRI and Wada Test in Epilepsy. 2021

Natalie N Htet, and Ricardo Pizarro, and Veena A Nair, and Daniel Y Chu, and Timothy Meier, and Evelyn Tunnell, and Paul Rutecki, and Bruce Hermann, and Elizabeth M Meyerand, and Vivek Prabhakaran
Department of Radiology, University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health, USA.

The intracarotid sodium amobarbital procedure (ISAP or Wada test) lateralizes cerebral functions to the cerebral hemispheres preoperatively. Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) is increasingly used to characterize preoperative language and memory lateralization. In this study, concordance of fMRI with Wada was examined in patients with medically intractable seizures. The relationship of the distance between the epileptogenic focus to functional activation area with patients' post-operative deficits in language was also analyzed. 27 epilepsy patients with preoperative fMRI and Wada data were analyzed using established fMRI paradigms for language and memory. Activation of Broca's and Wernicke's areas were measured in three dimensions. Language and memory lateralization were determined, and standard neuropsychiatry Wada test procedures were used for comparison. The shortest distance between a language area to the border of surgical focus (LAD) was also measured and compared with postoperative language deficits. Our study found that concordance between fMRI and Wada testing was 0.41 (Kappa's 'fair to good' concordance) for language dominance and 0.1 (Kappa's 'poor' concordance) for memory. No significant correlation was found between LAD and post-op language deficit (p=0.439). A correlation was found between LAD and post-op memory deficit (p=0.049; the further distance from surgical lesion to language area is associated with less post-operative memory loss). Females demonstrated significantly increased postoperative seizure improvement (Fisher's p-value=0.0296; female=8; male=6). A significant association between handedness (right-handed subjects) and postoperative seizure improvement was found (p=0.02) as well as a significant trend for interaction of gender and handedness on postoperative seizure improvement (p=0.09). Overall, our results demonstrate fMRI as a useful preoperative adjunct to Wada testing for language lateralization in patients with medically intractable seizures.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries

Related Publications

Natalie N Htet, and Ricardo Pizarro, and Veena A Nair, and Daniel Y Chu, and Timothy Meier, and Evelyn Tunnell, and Paul Rutecki, and Bruce Hermann, and Elizabeth M Meyerand, and Vivek Prabhakaran
September 2005, Neurology,
Natalie N Htet, and Ricardo Pizarro, and Veena A Nair, and Daniel Y Chu, and Timothy Meier, and Evelyn Tunnell, and Paul Rutecki, and Bruce Hermann, and Elizabeth M Meyerand, and Vivek Prabhakaran
September 2003, Neurology,
Natalie N Htet, and Ricardo Pizarro, and Veena A Nair, and Daniel Y Chu, and Timothy Meier, and Evelyn Tunnell, and Paul Rutecki, and Bruce Hermann, and Elizabeth M Meyerand, and Vivek Prabhakaran
February 2000, Revue neurologique,
Natalie N Htet, and Ricardo Pizarro, and Veena A Nair, and Daniel Y Chu, and Timothy Meier, and Evelyn Tunnell, and Paul Rutecki, and Bruce Hermann, and Elizabeth M Meyerand, and Vivek Prabhakaran
August 2006, Epilepsia,
Natalie N Htet, and Ricardo Pizarro, and Veena A Nair, and Daniel Y Chu, and Timothy Meier, and Evelyn Tunnell, and Paul Rutecki, and Bruce Hermann, and Elizabeth M Meyerand, and Vivek Prabhakaran
December 1995, Brain : a journal of neurology,
Natalie N Htet, and Ricardo Pizarro, and Veena A Nair, and Daniel Y Chu, and Timothy Meier, and Evelyn Tunnell, and Paul Rutecki, and Bruce Hermann, and Elizabeth M Meyerand, and Vivek Prabhakaran
July 2003, NeuroImage,
Natalie N Htet, and Ricardo Pizarro, and Veena A Nair, and Daniel Y Chu, and Timothy Meier, and Evelyn Tunnell, and Paul Rutecki, and Bruce Hermann, and Elizabeth M Meyerand, and Vivek Prabhakaran
January 2019, The Indian journal of radiology & imaging,
Natalie N Htet, and Ricardo Pizarro, and Veena A Nair, and Daniel Y Chu, and Timothy Meier, and Evelyn Tunnell, and Paul Rutecki, and Bruce Hermann, and Elizabeth M Meyerand, and Vivek Prabhakaran
January 1998, Stroke,
Natalie N Htet, and Ricardo Pizarro, and Veena A Nair, and Daniel Y Chu, and Timothy Meier, and Evelyn Tunnell, and Paul Rutecki, and Bruce Hermann, and Elizabeth M Meyerand, and Vivek Prabhakaran
February 2024, Acta neurochirurgica,
Natalie N Htet, and Ricardo Pizarro, and Veena A Nair, and Daniel Y Chu, and Timothy Meier, and Evelyn Tunnell, and Paul Rutecki, and Bruce Hermann, and Elizabeth M Meyerand, and Vivek Prabhakaran
June 2009, Journal of Korean Neurosurgical Society,
Copied contents to your clipboard!