Toolkit for detecting misused epidemiological methods. 2021

Colin L Soskolne, and Shira Kramer, and Juan Pablo Ramos-Bonilla, and Daniele Mandrioli, and Jennifer Sass, and Michael Gochfeld, and Carl F Cranor, and Shailesh Advani, and Lisa A Bero
School of Public Health, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada. colin.soskolne@ualberta.ca.

Critical knowledge of what we know about health and disease, risk factors, causation, prevention, and treatment, derives from epidemiology. Unfortunately, its methods and language can be misused and improperly applied. A repertoire of methods, techniques, arguments, and tactics are used by some people to manipulate science, usually in the service of powerful interests, and particularly those with a financial stake related to toxic agents. Such interests work to foment uncertainty, cast doubt, and mislead decision makers by seeding confusion about cause-and-effect relating to population health. We have compiled a toolkit of the methods used by those whose interests are not aligned with the public health sciences. Professional epidemiologists, as well as those who rely on their work, will thereby be more readily equipped to detect bias and flaws resulting from financial conflict-of-interest, improper study design, data collection, analysis, or interpretation, bringing greater clarity-not only to the advancement of knowledge, but, more immediately, to policy debates. The summary of techniques used to manipulate epidemiological findings, compiled as part of the 2020 Position Statement of the International Network for Epidemiology in Policy (INEP) entitled Conflict-of-Interest and Disclosure in Epidemiology, has been expanded and further elucidated in this commentary. Some level of uncertainty is inherent in science. However, corrupted and incomplete literature contributes to confuse, foment further uncertainty, and cast doubt about the evidence under consideration. Confusion delays scientific advancement and leads to the inability of policymakers to make changes that, if enacted, would-supported by the body of valid evidence-protect, maintain, and improve public health. An accessible toolkit is provided that brings attention to the misuse of the methods of epidemiology. Its usefulness is as a compendium of what those trained in epidemiology, as well as those reviewing epidemiological studies, should identify methodologically when assessing the transparency and validity of any epidemiological inquiry, evaluation, or argument. The problems resulting from financial conflicting interests and the misuse of scientific methods, in conjunction with the strategies that can be used to safeguard public health against them, apply not only to epidemiologists, but also to other public health professionals. This novel toolkit is for use in protecting the public. It is provided to assist public health professionals as gatekeepers of their respective specialty and subspecialty disciplines whose mission includes protecting, maintaining, and improving the public's health. It is intended to serve our roles as educators, reviewers, and researchers.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D012107 Research Design A plan for collecting and utilizing data so that desired information can be obtained with sufficient precision or so that an hypothesis can be tested properly. Experimental Design,Data Adjustment,Data Reporting,Design, Experimental,Designs, Experimental,Error Sources,Experimental Designs,Matched Groups,Methodology, Research,Problem Formulation,Research Methodology,Research Proposal,Research Strategy,Research Technics,Research Techniques,Scoring Methods,Adjustment, Data,Adjustments, Data,Data Adjustments,Design, Research,Designs, Research,Error Source,Formulation, Problem,Formulations, Problem,Group, Matched,Groups, Matched,Matched Group,Method, Scoring,Methods, Scoring,Problem Formulations,Proposal, Research,Proposals, Research,Reporting, Data,Research Designs,Research Proposals,Research Strategies,Research Technic,Research Technique,Scoring Method,Source, Error,Sources, Error,Strategies, Research,Strategy, Research,Technic, Research,Technics, Research,Technique, Research,Techniques, Research
D004812 Epidemiologic Methods Research techniques that focus on study designs and data gathering methods in human and animal populations. Epidemiologic Method,Epidemiological Methods,Methods, Epidemiologic,Epidemiological Method,Method, Epidemiologic,Method, Epidemiological,Methods, Epidemiological
D016265 Conflict of Interest A situation in which an individual might benefit personally from official or professional actions. It includes a conflict between a person's private interests and official responsibilities in a position of trust. The term is not restricted to government officials. The concept refers both to actual conflict of interest and the appearance or perception of conflict. Interest Conflict,Interest Conflicts
D035501 Uncertainty The condition in which reasonable knowledge regarding risks, benefits, or the future is not available.

Related Publications

Colin L Soskolne, and Shira Kramer, and Juan Pablo Ramos-Bonilla, and Daniele Mandrioli, and Jennifer Sass, and Michael Gochfeld, and Carl F Cranor, and Shailesh Advani, and Lisa A Bero
August 2022, Environmental health : a global access science source,
Colin L Soskolne, and Shira Kramer, and Juan Pablo Ramos-Bonilla, and Daniele Mandrioli, and Jennifer Sass, and Michael Gochfeld, and Carl F Cranor, and Shailesh Advani, and Lisa A Bero
February 2023, Environmental health : a global access science source,
Colin L Soskolne, and Shira Kramer, and Juan Pablo Ramos-Bonilla, and Daniele Mandrioli, and Jennifer Sass, and Michael Gochfeld, and Carl F Cranor, and Shailesh Advani, and Lisa A Bero
January 1988, IARC scientific publications,
Colin L Soskolne, and Shira Kramer, and Juan Pablo Ramos-Bonilla, and Daniele Mandrioli, and Jennifer Sass, and Michael Gochfeld, and Carl F Cranor, and Shailesh Advani, and Lisa A Bero
October 2006, Acta crystallographica. Section D, Biological crystallography,
Colin L Soskolne, and Shira Kramer, and Juan Pablo Ramos-Bonilla, and Daniele Mandrioli, and Jennifer Sass, and Michael Gochfeld, and Carl F Cranor, and Shailesh Advani, and Lisa A Bero
December 1970, Immunochemistry,
Colin L Soskolne, and Shira Kramer, and Juan Pablo Ramos-Bonilla, and Daniele Mandrioli, and Jennifer Sass, and Michael Gochfeld, and Carl F Cranor, and Shailesh Advani, and Lisa A Bero
November 2023, Advanced pharmaceutical bulletin,
Colin L Soskolne, and Shira Kramer, and Juan Pablo Ramos-Bonilla, and Daniele Mandrioli, and Jennifer Sass, and Michael Gochfeld, and Carl F Cranor, and Shailesh Advani, and Lisa A Bero
July 1996, Lancet (London, England),
Colin L Soskolne, and Shira Kramer, and Juan Pablo Ramos-Bonilla, and Daniele Mandrioli, and Jennifer Sass, and Michael Gochfeld, and Carl F Cranor, and Shailesh Advani, and Lisa A Bero
July 2005, Physical review letters,
Colin L Soskolne, and Shira Kramer, and Juan Pablo Ramos-Bonilla, and Daniele Mandrioli, and Jennifer Sass, and Michael Gochfeld, and Carl F Cranor, and Shailesh Advani, and Lisa A Bero
June 2000, Analytical chemistry,
Colin L Soskolne, and Shira Kramer, and Juan Pablo Ramos-Bonilla, and Daniele Mandrioli, and Jennifer Sass, and Michael Gochfeld, and Carl F Cranor, and Shailesh Advani, and Lisa A Bero
December 2018, Current opinion in genetics & development,
Copied contents to your clipboard!