Diagnostic criteria for blepharospasm: A multicenter international study. 2021

Giovanni Defazio, and Hyder A Jinnah, and Alfredo Berardelli, and Joel S Perlmutter, and Gamze Kilic Berkmen, and Brian D Berman, and Joseph Jankovic, and Tobias Bäumer, and Cynthia Comella, and Adam C Cotton, and Tommaso Ercoli, and Gina Ferrazzano, and Susan Fox, and Han-Joon Kim, and Emile Sami Moukheiber, and Sarah Pirio Richardson, and Anne Weissbach, and Laura J Wrigth, and Mark Hallett
Department of Medical Sciences and Public Health, University of Cagliari, Cagliari, Italy. Electronic address: giovanni.defazio@unica.it.

There are no widely accepted criteria to aid the physician in diagnosing BSP. To validate recently proposed diagnostic criteria for blepharospasm in a larger and geographically diverse population and to develop a screening system for blepharospasm. Video-recordings from 211 blepharospasm patients and 166 healthy/disease controls were examined by 8 raters. Agreement for presence of orbicularis oculi spasms, sensory trick, and increased blinking was measured by k statistics. Inability to voluntarily suppress the spasms was asked by the examiner but not captured in the video. Patients/controls were also requested to fill a self-administered questionnaire addressing relevant blepharospasm clinical aspects. The diagnosis at each site was the gold standard for sensitivity/specificity. All the study items yielded satisfactory inter/intra-observer agreement. Combination of items rather than each item alone reached satisfactory sensitivity/specificity. The combined algorithm started with recognition of spasms followed by sensory trick. In the absence of a sensory trick, including "increased blinking" or "inability to voluntarily suppress the spasms" or both items yielded 88-92% sensitivity and 79-83% specificity. No single question of the questionnaire yielded high sensitivity/specificity. Serial application of the questionnaire to our blepharospasm and control subjects and subsequent clinical examination of subjects screening positive by the validated diagnostic algorithms yielded 78-81% sensitivity and 83-91% specificity. These results support the use of proposed diagnostic criteria in multi-ethnic, multi-center cohorts. We also propose a case-finding procedure to screen blepharospasm in a given population with less effort than would be required by examination of all subjects.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D008297 Male Males
D008875 Middle Aged An adult aged 45 - 64 years. Middle Age
D010808 Physical Examination Systematic and thorough inspection of the patient for physical signs of disease or abnormality. Physical Exam,Examination, Physical,Physical Examinations and Diagnoses,Exam, Physical,Examinations, Physical,Exams, Physical,Physical Examinations,Physical Exams
D001764 Blepharospasm Excessive winking; tonic or clonic spasm of the orbicularis oculi muscle. Blepharospasms
D001767 Blinking Brief closing of the eyelids by involuntary normal periodic closing, as a protective measure, or by voluntary action. Orbicularis Oculi Reflex,Reflex, Blink,Reflex, Corneal,Reflex, Orbicularis Oculi,Winking,Blink Reflexes,Corneal Reflexes,Orbicularis Oculi Reflexes,Blink Reflex,Reflexes, Blink,Reflexes, Orbicularis Oculi
D005260 Female Females
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D012680 Sensitivity and Specificity Binary classification measures to assess test results. Sensitivity or recall rate is the proportion of true positives. Specificity is the probability of correctly determining the absence of a condition. (From Last, Dictionary of Epidemiology, 2d ed) Specificity,Sensitivity,Specificity and Sensitivity
D014741 Video Recording The storing or preserving of video signals to be played back later via a transmitter or receiver. Audiovisual Recording,Videorecording,Audiovisual Recordings,Recording, Audiovisual,Recording, Video,Recordings, Audiovisual,Recordings, Video,Video Recordings,Videorecordings
D016022 Case-Control Studies Comparisons that start with the identification of persons with the disease or outcome of interest and a control (comparison, referent) group without the disease or outcome of interest. The relationship of an attribute is examined by comparing both groups with regard to the frequency or levels of outcome over time. Case-Base Studies,Case-Comparison Studies,Case-Referent Studies,Matched Case-Control Studies,Nested Case-Control Studies,Case Control Studies,Case-Compeer Studies,Case-Referrent Studies,Case Base Studies,Case Comparison Studies,Case Control Study,Case Referent Studies,Case Referrent Studies,Case-Comparison Study,Case-Control Studies, Matched,Case-Control Studies, Nested,Case-Control Study,Case-Control Study, Matched,Case-Control Study, Nested,Case-Referent Study,Case-Referrent Study,Matched Case Control Studies,Matched Case-Control Study,Nested Case Control Studies,Nested Case-Control Study,Studies, Case Control,Studies, Case-Base,Studies, Case-Comparison,Studies, Case-Compeer,Studies, Case-Control,Studies, Case-Referent,Studies, Case-Referrent,Studies, Matched Case-Control,Studies, Nested Case-Control,Study, Case Control,Study, Case-Comparison,Study, Case-Control,Study, Case-Referent,Study, Case-Referrent,Study, Matched Case-Control,Study, Nested Case-Control

Related Publications

Giovanni Defazio, and Hyder A Jinnah, and Alfredo Berardelli, and Joel S Perlmutter, and Gamze Kilic Berkmen, and Brian D Berman, and Joseph Jankovic, and Tobias Bäumer, and Cynthia Comella, and Adam C Cotton, and Tommaso Ercoli, and Gina Ferrazzano, and Susan Fox, and Han-Joon Kim, and Emile Sami Moukheiber, and Sarah Pirio Richardson, and Anne Weissbach, and Laura J Wrigth, and Mark Hallett
October 2022, The ocular surface,
Giovanni Defazio, and Hyder A Jinnah, and Alfredo Berardelli, and Joel S Perlmutter, and Gamze Kilic Berkmen, and Brian D Berman, and Joseph Jankovic, and Tobias Bäumer, and Cynthia Comella, and Adam C Cotton, and Tommaso Ercoli, and Gina Ferrazzano, and Susan Fox, and Han-Joon Kim, and Emile Sami Moukheiber, and Sarah Pirio Richardson, and Anne Weissbach, and Laura J Wrigth, and Mark Hallett
August 2016, Neurology,
Giovanni Defazio, and Hyder A Jinnah, and Alfredo Berardelli, and Joel S Perlmutter, and Gamze Kilic Berkmen, and Brian D Berman, and Joseph Jankovic, and Tobias Bäumer, and Cynthia Comella, and Adam C Cotton, and Tommaso Ercoli, and Gina Ferrazzano, and Susan Fox, and Han-Joon Kim, and Emile Sami Moukheiber, and Sarah Pirio Richardson, and Anne Weissbach, and Laura J Wrigth, and Mark Hallett
February 2017, Neurology,
Giovanni Defazio, and Hyder A Jinnah, and Alfredo Berardelli, and Joel S Perlmutter, and Gamze Kilic Berkmen, and Brian D Berman, and Joseph Jankovic, and Tobias Bäumer, and Cynthia Comella, and Adam C Cotton, and Tommaso Ercoli, and Gina Ferrazzano, and Susan Fox, and Han-Joon Kim, and Emile Sami Moukheiber, and Sarah Pirio Richardson, and Anne Weissbach, and Laura J Wrigth, and Mark Hallett
March 2005, Thyroid : official journal of the American Thyroid Association,
Giovanni Defazio, and Hyder A Jinnah, and Alfredo Berardelli, and Joel S Perlmutter, and Gamze Kilic Berkmen, and Brian D Berman, and Joseph Jankovic, and Tobias Bäumer, and Cynthia Comella, and Adam C Cotton, and Tommaso Ercoli, and Gina Ferrazzano, and Susan Fox, and Han-Joon Kim, and Emile Sami Moukheiber, and Sarah Pirio Richardson, and Anne Weissbach, and Laura J Wrigth, and Mark Hallett
August 1994, Cephalalgia : an international journal of headache,
Giovanni Defazio, and Hyder A Jinnah, and Alfredo Berardelli, and Joel S Perlmutter, and Gamze Kilic Berkmen, and Brian D Berman, and Joseph Jankovic, and Tobias Bäumer, and Cynthia Comella, and Adam C Cotton, and Tommaso Ercoli, and Gina Ferrazzano, and Susan Fox, and Han-Joon Kim, and Emile Sami Moukheiber, and Sarah Pirio Richardson, and Anne Weissbach, and Laura J Wrigth, and Mark Hallett
February 2017, Journal of clinical psychopharmacology,
Giovanni Defazio, and Hyder A Jinnah, and Alfredo Berardelli, and Joel S Perlmutter, and Gamze Kilic Berkmen, and Brian D Berman, and Joseph Jankovic, and Tobias Bäumer, and Cynthia Comella, and Adam C Cotton, and Tommaso Ercoli, and Gina Ferrazzano, and Susan Fox, and Han-Joon Kim, and Emile Sami Moukheiber, and Sarah Pirio Richardson, and Anne Weissbach, and Laura J Wrigth, and Mark Hallett
June 2017, Journal of hepato-biliary-pancreatic sciences,
Giovanni Defazio, and Hyder A Jinnah, and Alfredo Berardelli, and Joel S Perlmutter, and Gamze Kilic Berkmen, and Brian D Berman, and Joseph Jankovic, and Tobias Bäumer, and Cynthia Comella, and Adam C Cotton, and Tommaso Ercoli, and Gina Ferrazzano, and Susan Fox, and Han-Joon Kim, and Emile Sami Moukheiber, and Sarah Pirio Richardson, and Anne Weissbach, and Laura J Wrigth, and Mark Hallett
April 2008, Clinical journal of gastroenterology,
Giovanni Defazio, and Hyder A Jinnah, and Alfredo Berardelli, and Joel S Perlmutter, and Gamze Kilic Berkmen, and Brian D Berman, and Joseph Jankovic, and Tobias Bäumer, and Cynthia Comella, and Adam C Cotton, and Tommaso Ercoli, and Gina Ferrazzano, and Susan Fox, and Han-Joon Kim, and Emile Sami Moukheiber, and Sarah Pirio Richardson, and Anne Weissbach, and Laura J Wrigth, and Mark Hallett
January 2018, International journal of cardiology,
Giovanni Defazio, and Hyder A Jinnah, and Alfredo Berardelli, and Joel S Perlmutter, and Gamze Kilic Berkmen, and Brian D Berman, and Joseph Jankovic, and Tobias Bäumer, and Cynthia Comella, and Adam C Cotton, and Tommaso Ercoli, and Gina Ferrazzano, and Susan Fox, and Han-Joon Kim, and Emile Sami Moukheiber, and Sarah Pirio Richardson, and Anne Weissbach, and Laura J Wrigth, and Mark Hallett
September 2017, European heart journal,
Copied contents to your clipboard!