Understating how antibiotic tolerance impacts subsequent resistance development in the clinical setting is important to identifying effective therapeutic interventions and prevention measures. This study describes a patient case of methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) bacteremia which rapidly developed resistance to three primary MRSA therapies and identifies genetic and metabolic changes selected in vivo that are associated with rapid resistance evolution. Index blood cultures displayed susceptibility to all (non-beta-lactam) antibiotics with the exception of trimethoprim/ sulfamethoxazole. One month after initial presentation, during the same encounter, blood cultures were again positive for MRSA, now displaying intermediate resistance to vancomycin and ceftaroline and resistance to daptomycin. Two weeks later, blood cultures were positive for a third time, still intermediate resistant to vancomycin and ceftaroline and resistant to daptomycin. Mutations in mprF and vraT were common to all multidrug resistant isolates whereas mutations in tagH, agrB and saeR and secondary mprF mutation emerged sequentially and transiently resulting in distinct in vitro phenotypes. The baseline mutation rate of the patient isolates was unremarkable ruling out the hypermutator phenotype as a contributor to the rapid emergence of resistance. However, the index isolate demonstrated pronounced tolerance to the antibiotic daptomycin, a phenotype that facilitates the subsequent development of resistance during antibiotic exposure. This study exemplifies the capacity of antibiotic-tolerant pathogens to rapidly develop both stable and transient genetic and phenotypic changes, over the course of a single patient encounter.