Epistemic anxiety and epistemic risk. 2022

Lilith Newton
School of Philosophy, Psychology and Language Sciences, University of Edinburgh, 3 Charles Street, EH8 9AD Edinburgh, UK.

In this paper, I provide an account of epistemic anxiety as an emotional response to epistemic risk: the risk of believing in error. The motivation for this account is threefold. First, it makes epistemic anxiety a species of anxiety, thus rendering psychologically respectable a notion that has heretofore been taken seriously only by epistemologists. Second, it illuminates the relationship between anxiety and risk. It is standard in psychology to conceive of anxiety as a response to risk, but psychologists - very reasonably - have little to say about risk itself, as opposed to risk judgement. In this paper, I specify what risk must be like to be the kind of thing to which anxiety can be a response. Third, my account improves on extant accounts of epistemic anxiety in the literature. It is more fleshed out than Jennifer Nagel's (2010a), which is largely agnostic about the nature of epistemic anxiety, focusing instead on what work it does in our epistemic lives. In offering an account of epistemic anxiety as an emotion, my account explains how it is able to do the epistemological work to which Nagel puts it. My account is also more plausible than Juliette Vazard's (2018, 2021), on which epistemic anxiety is an emotional response to potential threat to one's practical interests. Vazard's account cannot distinguish epistemic anxiety from anxiety in general, and also fails to capture all instances of what we want to call epistemic anxiety. My account does better on both counts.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries

Related Publications

Lilith Newton
April 2007, Integrated environmental assessment and management,
Lilith Newton
June 2023, Philosophical studies,
Lilith Newton
January 2022, Kennedy Institute of Ethics journal,
Lilith Newton
August 2008, The Journal of medicine and philosophy,
Lilith Newton
June 1996, Risk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis,
Lilith Newton
May 2023, Science and engineering ethics,
Lilith Newton
October 2022, Journal of evaluation in clinical practice,
Lilith Newton
February 2012, The Journal of medicine and philosophy,
Lilith Newton
March 2015, Risk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis,
Copied contents to your clipboard!