Sources of subjective variability in the assessment of left ventricular regional wall motion from contrast ventriculograms. 1987

W G Kussmaul, and J P Kleaveland, and G R Zeevi, and J W Hirshfeld

Intraobserver and interobserver variability in the subjective interpretation of angiographic regional wall motion was quantitated in 135 contrast left ventriculograms showing a wide range of normal and abnormal cardiac function, and the effects of rating-scale complexity and myocardial regional differences were examined. Three experienced observers separately graded endocardial motion on a 6-point scale (0 = normal to 5 = dyskinesia) in each of 5 regions. Scores were also tabulated on a 3-point scale and as normal or abnormal. Average intraobserver agreement (2 evaluations per observer) was 68% using the 6-point scale, 86% using the 3-point scale and 90% for normal/abnormal. Interobserver agreement (3 observers) was 47% for exact agreement using the 6-point scale, 75% using the 3-point scale and 80% for normal/abnormal. Interobserver agreement was 84% within a range of 1 wall motion grade on the 6-point scale. Subjectively normal wall motion was most frequent in the 2 basal segments and least frequent in the apical and anterolateral segments. Disagreements were most frequent in the latter 2 segments, but when normal segments were excluded, these interregional differences disappeared. Thus, intraobserver and interobserver agreement is higher than previously reported, and may exceed 80%. Variability depends on whether regional wall motion is normal, but is also affected by the complexity of the rating scale. The distinctions implied by a 6-point subjective rating scale are probably not reliable, but variability is greatly reduced by use of a simplified scoring system.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D009200 Myocardial Contraction Contractile activity of the MYOCARDIUM. Heart Contractility,Inotropism, Cardiac,Cardiac Inotropism,Cardiac Inotropisms,Contractilities, Heart,Contractility, Heart,Contraction, Myocardial,Contractions, Myocardial,Heart Contractilities,Inotropisms, Cardiac,Myocardial Contractions
D006331 Heart Diseases Pathological conditions involving the HEART including its structural and functional abnormalities. Cardiac Disorders,Heart Disorders,Cardiac Diseases,Cardiac Disease,Cardiac Disorder,Heart Disease,Heart Disorder
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000790 Angiocardiography Radiography of the heart and great vessels after injection of a contrast medium. Angiocardiographies

Related Publications

W G Kussmaul, and J P Kleaveland, and G R Zeevi, and J W Hirshfeld
August 2003, Physiological measurement,
W G Kussmaul, and J P Kleaveland, and G R Zeevi, and J W Hirshfeld
September 1983, Circulation,
W G Kussmaul, and J P Kleaveland, and G R Zeevi, and J W Hirshfeld
December 1999, The American journal of cardiology,
W G Kussmaul, and J P Kleaveland, and G R Zeevi, and J W Hirshfeld
September 1980, Circulation,
W G Kussmaul, and J P Kleaveland, and G R Zeevi, and J W Hirshfeld
October 1997, International journal of cardiac imaging,
W G Kussmaul, and J P Kleaveland, and G R Zeevi, and J W Hirshfeld
October 2003, Echocardiography (Mount Kisco, N.Y.),
W G Kussmaul, and J P Kleaveland, and G R Zeevi, and J W Hirshfeld
March 2005, Arquivos brasileiros de cardiologia,
W G Kussmaul, and J P Kleaveland, and G R Zeevi, and J W Hirshfeld
January 1982, Catheterization and cardiovascular diagnosis,
W G Kussmaul, and J P Kleaveland, and G R Zeevi, and J W Hirshfeld
February 2002, Journal of the American Society of Echocardiography : official publication of the American Society of Echocardiography,
W G Kussmaul, and J P Kleaveland, and G R Zeevi, and J W Hirshfeld
January 1976, Archivos del Instituto de Cardiologia de Mexico,
Copied contents to your clipboard!