Thymomas are a rare neoplasm of the anterior mediastinum and often associated with paraneoplastic syndromes. Though myasthenia gravis is the most common and well-known, the list of reported paraneoplastic syndromes occurring with thymoma is extensive and ever-growing. Paraneoplastic syndromes can involve nearly every organ system, including hematologic abnormalities affecting any or all cell lines. This can present challenges to the clinician in terms of diagnosis, prognostic impact, and management. We present the case of a previously healthy 41-year-old female who was diagnosed with thymoma and three rare hematologic paraneoplastic syndromes: pure red cell aplasia (PRCA), autoimmune hemolytic anemia (AIHA), and T-cell large granular lymphocytic leukemia (T-LGLL). To the best of our knowledge, there have been only four other reported cases of PRCA and AIHA in a single patient with thymoma, all of which were treated with thymectomy. Upfront surgical resection was not possible in the present case and thus the patient was alternatively treated with corticosteroids and octreotide, which proved successful in resolving the anemia. The authors present this case to share these findings of an alternative treatment strategy for thymoma-associated PRCA and AIHA and to highlight the importance of careful monitoring with routine blood work for these complex patients.