Shared decision making with black patients: A scoping review. 2023

Nada Mhaimeed, and Narjis Mhaimeed, and Omar Mhaimeed, and Jamal Alanni, and Zain Burney, and Abdallah Elshafeey, and Sa'ad Laws, and Justin J Choi
Weill Cornell Medicine-Qatar, Doha, Qatar. Electronic address: nam2053@qatar-med.cornell.edu.

The purpose of this review is to explore the breadth of research conducted on SDM in the care of Black patients. We conducted a scoping review following the methodological framework outlined by the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) checklist. We searched articles related to original research on SDM in the care of Black patients in October 2022 using PubMed, Embase, and Google Scholar databases. Articles of all study designs (quantitative and qualitative), published or translated into English, were included. A standardized data extraction form and thematic analysis were used to facilitate data extraction by two independent reviewers. After removal of duplicates and screening, 30 articles were included in the final analysis. Black patients and clinician were found to not share the same understanding of SDM, and patients highly valued SDM in their care. Interventions to improve SDM yielded mixed results to enhance intent, participation in SDM, as well as health outcomes. Decision aids were the most effective form of intervention to enhance SDM. The most common barrier to SDM was patient-clinician communication, and was exacerbated by racial discordance, clinician mistrust, past experiences, and paternalistic clinician-patient dynamics. SDM has the potential to improve health outcomes in Black patients when implemented contextually within Black patients' experiences and concerns. Significant barriers such as clinician mistrust exist, and the overall perception in the Black community is that SDM does not occur sufficiently. Barriers to SDM seem to be most pronounced when there is patient-clinician racial discordance. Several interventions aimed at improving SDM with Black patients have shown mixed results. Future studies should evaluate larger-scale interventions with longer follow-up. Practice implications Shared decision making (SDM) has been proposed as a useful tool for improving quality and equity in Black patients' care. However, Black patients experience lower rates of SDM compared to other populations. SDM has the potential to improve health outcomes in Black patients when implemented contextually within Black patients' experiences and concerns.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D010358 Patient Participation Patient involvement in the decision-making process in matters pertaining to health. Patient Activation,Patient Empowerment,Patient Engagement,Patient Involvement,Patient Participation Rates,Activation, Patient,Empowerment, Patient,Engagement, Patient,Involvement, Patient,Participation Rate, Patient,Participation Rates, Patient,Participation, Patient,Patient Participation Rate
D003142 Communication The exchange or transmission of ideas, attitudes, or beliefs between individuals or groups. Miscommunication,Misinformation,Social Communication,Communication Programs,Communications Personnel,Personal Communication,Communication Program,Communication, Personal,Communication, Social,Communications, Social,Miscommunications,Misinformations,Personnel, Communications,Program, Communication,Programs, Communication,Social Communications
D003657 Decision Making The process of making a selective intellectual judgment when presented with several complex alternatives consisting of several variables, and usually defining a course of action or an idea. Credit Assignment,Assignment, Credit,Assignments, Credit,Credit Assignments
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000080536 Decision Making, Shared Collaborative process of reaching a decision. Shared Decision Making
D044383 Black People Persons having origins in any of the black racial groups of AFRICA. Note that OMB category BLACK OR AFRICAN AMERICAN is available for the United States population groups. Race and ethnicity terms, as used in the federal government, are self-identified social construct and may include terms outdated and offensive in MeSH to assist users who are interested in retrieving comprehensive search results for studies such as in longitudinal studies. African Continental Ancestry Group,Black Person,Negroid Race,Black Peoples,Black Persons,Negroid Races,People, Black,Person, Black,Persons, Black,Race, Negroid

Related Publications

Nada Mhaimeed, and Narjis Mhaimeed, and Omar Mhaimeed, and Jamal Alanni, and Zain Burney, and Abdallah Elshafeey, and Sa'ad Laws, and Justin J Choi
January 2016, Professioni infermieristiche,
Nada Mhaimeed, and Narjis Mhaimeed, and Omar Mhaimeed, and Jamal Alanni, and Zain Burney, and Abdallah Elshafeey, and Sa'ad Laws, and Justin J Choi
May 2022, American journal of ophthalmology,
Nada Mhaimeed, and Narjis Mhaimeed, and Omar Mhaimeed, and Jamal Alanni, and Zain Burney, and Abdallah Elshafeey, and Sa'ad Laws, and Justin J Choi
September 2021, Acta neurochirurgica,
Nada Mhaimeed, and Narjis Mhaimeed, and Omar Mhaimeed, and Jamal Alanni, and Zain Burney, and Abdallah Elshafeey, and Sa'ad Laws, and Justin J Choi
March 2021, JAMA dermatology,
Nada Mhaimeed, and Narjis Mhaimeed, and Omar Mhaimeed, and Jamal Alanni, and Zain Burney, and Abdallah Elshafeey, and Sa'ad Laws, and Justin J Choi
October 2022, Seminars in arthritis and rheumatism,
Nada Mhaimeed, and Narjis Mhaimeed, and Omar Mhaimeed, and Jamal Alanni, and Zain Burney, and Abdallah Elshafeey, and Sa'ad Laws, and Justin J Choi
May 2023, Dementia (London, England),
Nada Mhaimeed, and Narjis Mhaimeed, and Omar Mhaimeed, and Jamal Alanni, and Zain Burney, and Abdallah Elshafeey, and Sa'ad Laws, and Justin J Choi
September 2022, BMJ open,
Nada Mhaimeed, and Narjis Mhaimeed, and Omar Mhaimeed, and Jamal Alanni, and Zain Burney, and Abdallah Elshafeey, and Sa'ad Laws, and Justin J Choi
May 2023, Nursing ethics,
Nada Mhaimeed, and Narjis Mhaimeed, and Omar Mhaimeed, and Jamal Alanni, and Zain Burney, and Abdallah Elshafeey, and Sa'ad Laws, and Justin J Choi
January 2021, Patient preference and adherence,
Nada Mhaimeed, and Narjis Mhaimeed, and Omar Mhaimeed, and Jamal Alanni, and Zain Burney, and Abdallah Elshafeey, and Sa'ad Laws, and Justin J Choi
October 2023, Current problems in cardiology,
Copied contents to your clipboard!