SAGES perspective: professional medical associations, commercial interests, and conflicts of interest. 2023

Phillip Shadduck, and Patricia Sylla, and Erin Schwarz, and Caroline Reinke, and Peter Denk, and Shelley Ginsberg, and Horacio Asbun, and Aurora Pryor
Duke Regional Hospital & NC Specialty Hospital, Durham, NC, USA. phil9128@aol.com.

Professional medical associations (PMAs) have an essential role in advancing medical care and health. PMAs promote skills training, clinical standards, and other important educational activities. Most often, PMAs are not-for-profit entities that rely upon funding from industry to help cover the costs of these valuable activities. Equally important, innovation and progress in surgery require physician collaboration with industry throughout the product development process. SAGES has opined that, with appropriate Conflict of Interest (COI) disclosure and management processes, PMA educational activities can be both scientifically and ethically sound. SAGES has developed and implemented comprehensive and stringent processes for managing potential COI within the organization, at the annual meeting, and in developing educational offerings. This document reviews the SAGES COI processes and results 2009-2021. Implementation of the SAGES COI disclosure and management processes reduced the reported perceived incidence of bias at the annual meeting from 4.4-6.2% (2008-2010) to 1.2-2.2% (2011-2013). Recent comparison of reported disclosures revealed a rise in number of speakers with financial relationships and an increase in reporting of disclosures in presentations without an associated increase in need for conflict resolution by the COI committee. Despite good overall adherence to COI policies, SAGES was recently cited for non-compliance with ACCME standards related to inclusion of faculty with ownership interest. This experience highlighted the potential for discordance in the interpretation of whether disclosures relate to specific CME content. SAGES COI processes have since been updated to reflect the more stringent 2020 ACCME Standards that exclude speakers and planners with ownership interest from any CME activity. The SAGES experience with disclosure and mitigation of financial relationships highlights the challenges of validating the accuracy of physician disclosures and establishing the relevance of financial relationships to the content of accredited educational activities. SAGES will continue to streamline its COI disclosure process with specific focus on aligning all financial disclosures among the various reporting platforms.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D010820 Physicians Individuals licensed to practice medicine. Physician
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D016265 Conflict of Interest A situation in which an individual might benefit personally from official or professional actions. It includes a conflict between a person's private interests and official responsibilities in a position of trust. The term is not restricted to government officials. The concept refers both to actual conflict of interest and the appearance or perception of conflict. Interest Conflict,Interest Conflicts
D030881 Disclosure Revealing of information, by oral or written communication. Financial Disclosure,Information Disclosure,Disclosure, Financial,Disclosure, Information,Disclosures, Financial,Financial Disclosures

Related Publications

Phillip Shadduck, and Patricia Sylla, and Erin Schwarz, and Caroline Reinke, and Peter Denk, and Shelley Ginsberg, and Horacio Asbun, and Aurora Pryor
January 2010, Annals of family medicine,
Phillip Shadduck, and Patricia Sylla, and Erin Schwarz, and Caroline Reinke, and Peter Denk, and Shelley Ginsberg, and Horacio Asbun, and Aurora Pryor
May 2017, JAMA,
Phillip Shadduck, and Patricia Sylla, and Erin Schwarz, and Caroline Reinke, and Peter Denk, and Shelley Ginsberg, and Horacio Asbun, and Aurora Pryor
January 2019, Surgical neurology international,
Phillip Shadduck, and Patricia Sylla, and Erin Schwarz, and Caroline Reinke, and Peter Denk, and Shelley Ginsberg, and Horacio Asbun, and Aurora Pryor
September 2016, Fortschritte der Neurologie-Psychiatrie,
Phillip Shadduck, and Patricia Sylla, and Erin Schwarz, and Caroline Reinke, and Peter Denk, and Shelley Ginsberg, and Horacio Asbun, and Aurora Pryor
January 1995, The Journal of clinical ethics,
Phillip Shadduck, and Patricia Sylla, and Erin Schwarz, and Caroline Reinke, and Peter Denk, and Shelley Ginsberg, and Horacio Asbun, and Aurora Pryor
January 1996, The Journal of clinical ethics,
Phillip Shadduck, and Patricia Sylla, and Erin Schwarz, and Caroline Reinke, and Peter Denk, and Shelley Ginsberg, and Horacio Asbun, and Aurora Pryor
January 1996, The Journal of clinical ethics,
Phillip Shadduck, and Patricia Sylla, and Erin Schwarz, and Caroline Reinke, and Peter Denk, and Shelley Ginsberg, and Horacio Asbun, and Aurora Pryor
January 1997, Health law journal,
Phillip Shadduck, and Patricia Sylla, and Erin Schwarz, and Caroline Reinke, and Peter Denk, and Shelley Ginsberg, and Horacio Asbun, and Aurora Pryor
January 2003, International journal of health services : planning, administration, evaluation,
Phillip Shadduck, and Patricia Sylla, and Erin Schwarz, and Caroline Reinke, and Peter Denk, and Shelley Ginsberg, and Horacio Asbun, and Aurora Pryor
January 2006, Perspective infirmiere : revue officielle de l'Ordre des infirmieres et infirmiers du Quebec,
Copied contents to your clipboard!