Short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs), the end products of gut microbial fermentation of dietary fibers and non-digestible polysaccharides, act as a link between the microbiome, immune system, and inflammatory processes. The importance of accurately quantifying SCFAs in plasma has recently emerged to understand their biological role. In this work, a sensitive and reproducible LC-MS/MS method is reported for SCFAs quantification in three different matrices such as human, rat and mouse plasma via derivatization, using as derivatizing agent O-benzylhydroxylamine (O-BHA), coupled with liquid-liquid extraction. First, the instrumental parameters of the mass spectrometer and then the chromatographic conditions were optimized using previously SCFAs derivatives synthetized and used as standards. After that, the best conditions for derivatization and extraction from plasma were studied and a series of determinations were performed on human, rat, and mouse plasma aliquots to validate the overall method (derivatization, extraction, and LC-MS/MS determination). The method showed good performance in terms of recovery (> 80%), precision (RSD <14%), accuracy (RE < ± 10%) and sensitivity (LOQ of 0.01 µM for acetic, butyric, propionic and isobutyric acid) in all plasma samples. The method thus developed and validated was applied to the quantification of major SCFAs in adult and aged mice, germ-free mice and in germ-free recipient mice subjected to fecal transplant from adult and aged donors. Results highlighted how plasma concentrations of SCFAs are correlated with age further highlighting the importance of developing a method that is reliable for the quantification of SCFAs to study their biological role.