Mononuclear copper complexes relevant to the active site of copper nitrite reductases (CuNiRs) are known to be catalytically active for the reduction of nitrite. Yet, their catalytic mechanism has thus far not been resolved. Here, we provide a complete description of the electrocatalytic nitrite reduction mechanism of a bio-inspired CuNiR catalyst Cu(tmpa) (tmpa = tris(2-pyridylmethyl)amine) in aqueous solution. Through a combination of electrochemical studies, reaction kinetics, and density functional theory (DFT) computations, we show that the protonation steps take place in a stepwise manner and are decoupled from electron transfer. The rate-determining step is a general acid-catalyzed protonation of a copper-ligated nitrous acid (HNO2) species. In view of the growing urge to convert nitrogen-containing compounds, this work provides principal reaction parameters for efficient electrochemical nitrite reduction. This contributes to the investigation and development of nitrite reduction catalysts, which is crucial to restore the biogeochemical nitrogen cycle.