BACKGROUND Chordoid glioma is a rare well-circumscribed glial neoplasm arising in adults and predominantly affects females. Tanycytes of the third ventricle have been proposed as the cell of origin owing to its location. It is characterized by chordoid features with myxoid and inflammatory stroma and recurrent PRKCA p.D463H missense mutation. METHODS We present two cases (30-year-old female and 45-year-old male) with similar complaints of behavioral change and headache. Midline suprasellar homogeneously enhancing mass was seen on contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging. Histopathology and immunohistochemistry was characteristic of chordoid glioma with cords and clusters of epithelioid cells arranged in a solid pattern. There were variable amounts of myxoid stroma and lymphoplasmacytic infiltrate. No mitosis, necrosis, or brain invasion was noted. The cells expressed strong diffuse positivity for glial fibrillary acid protein (GFAP) and weak nuclear thyroid transcription factor (TTF-1). Epithelial membrane antigen (EMA)and brachyury were negative. Subsequently, the lady underwent gross total excision and died soon after the operation. The male patient received radiotherapy and is currently doing well after 6 months of follow-up. CONCLUSIONS The rare occurrence as well as the radiological and morphological overlaps in chordoid gliomas make them a true masquerader. Combination of GFAP and TTF-1 in the immunohistochemical panel can be useful in differential diagnosis. Mainstay of treatment is complete surgical excision, with adjuvant radiotherapy becoming increasingly important.