Does acute cannabidiol (CBD) use impair performance? A meta-analysis and comparison with placebo and delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol (THC). 2024

Lindsay A Lo, and April L Christiansen, and Justin C Strickland, and Carly A Pistawka, and Lauren Eadie, and Ryan Vandrey, and Caroline A MacCallum
Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.

Cannabidiol (CBD) is widely used and believed to be non-intoxicating, lacking acute performance effects (e.g., non-impairing). However, a synthesis of data has not evaluated this. This meta-analysis synthesized data from controlled human laboratory studies that evaluated if acute CBD use impairs performance. Performance on objective and subjective measures of cognitive and psychomotor function were used as markers for potential performance changes and impairment. Studies were identified through systematic database searches. Adult clinical trials measuring acute CBD effects (within 0-8 h of administration) were included. The primary outcome was the peak mean difference in performance measures between CBD and placebo. A secondary analysis utilizing delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol (Δ9-THC) as a positive control for comparison to CBD was completed. Pooled Hedges' g estimates were calculated using robust variance estimation (RVE) meta-regression. The omnibus RVE meta-analysis indicated a statistically significant, but small effect size (Hedge's g < 0.2) for impaired performance following acute CBD consumption compared to placebo (N = 16 trials, Hedges' g = 0.122, 95% CI: 0.023-0.221, p = 0.019). Measure type was a significant moderator with larger mean differences between CBD and placebo when subjective measures, specifically self-reported sedation, were used versus objective performance tasks (Hedges' gSubjective = 0.288 versus Hedges' gObjective = 0.048). Δ9-THC had a significantly greater magnitude of impairment compared to CBD (N = 8, Hedges' g = 0.416, 95% CI: 0.017-0.816, p = 0.043). In summary, acute CBD consumption was associated with a small increase in subjective ratings of sedation, but no difference from placebo was observed across multiple domains of objectively assessed cognitive or psychomotor performance. These findings suggest that acute CBD alone is unlikely to significantly impair daily functioning or workplace performance.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries

Related Publications

Lindsay A Lo, and April L Christiansen, and Justin C Strickland, and Carly A Pistawka, and Lauren Eadie, and Ryan Vandrey, and Caroline A MacCallum
December 2019, Neuroscience and biobehavioral reviews,
Lindsay A Lo, and April L Christiansen, and Justin C Strickland, and Carly A Pistawka, and Lauren Eadie, and Ryan Vandrey, and Caroline A MacCallum
May 2021, Addiction (Abingdon, England),
Lindsay A Lo, and April L Christiansen, and Justin C Strickland, and Carly A Pistawka, and Lauren Eadie, and Ryan Vandrey, and Caroline A MacCallum
November 2022, Psychopharmacology,
Lindsay A Lo, and April L Christiansen, and Justin C Strickland, and Carly A Pistawka, and Lauren Eadie, and Ryan Vandrey, and Caroline A MacCallum
October 2014, BMC pharmacology & toxicology,
Lindsay A Lo, and April L Christiansen, and Justin C Strickland, and Carly A Pistawka, and Lauren Eadie, and Ryan Vandrey, and Caroline A MacCallum
August 2002, Forensic science international,
Lindsay A Lo, and April L Christiansen, and Justin C Strickland, and Carly A Pistawka, and Lauren Eadie, and Ryan Vandrey, and Caroline A MacCallum
November 2019, Brain, behavior, and immunity,
Lindsay A Lo, and April L Christiansen, and Justin C Strickland, and Carly A Pistawka, and Lauren Eadie, and Ryan Vandrey, and Caroline A MacCallum
March 2022, The International journal on drug policy,
Lindsay A Lo, and April L Christiansen, and Justin C Strickland, and Carly A Pistawka, and Lauren Eadie, and Ryan Vandrey, and Caroline A MacCallum
March 2023, Drug and alcohol dependence,
Lindsay A Lo, and April L Christiansen, and Justin C Strickland, and Carly A Pistawka, and Lauren Eadie, and Ryan Vandrey, and Caroline A MacCallum
February 2003, Neuropsychopharmacology : official publication of the American College of Neuropsychopharmacology,
Lindsay A Lo, and April L Christiansen, and Justin C Strickland, and Carly A Pistawka, and Lauren Eadie, and Ryan Vandrey, and Caroline A MacCallum
August 2022, Drug and alcohol dependence,
Copied contents to your clipboard!