Robustness analysis of dynamic trajectory radiotherapy and volumetric modulated arc therapy plans for head and neck cancer. 2024

Hannes A Loebner, and Jenny Bertholet, and Paul-Henry Mackeprang, and Werner Volken, and Olgun Elicin, and Silvan Mueller, and Gian Guyer, and Daniel M Aebersold, and Marco F M Stampanoni, and Michael K Fix, and Peter Manser
Division of Medical Radiation Physics and Department of Radiation Oncology, Inselspital, Bern University Hospital, and University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland.

Dynamic trajectory radiotherapy (DTRT) has been shown to improve healthy tissue sparing compared to volumetric arc therapy (VMAT). This study aimed to assess and compare the robustness of DTRT and VMAT treatment-plans for head and neck (H&N) cancer to patient-setup (PS) and machine-positioning uncertainties. The robustness of DTRT and VMAT plans previously created for 46 H&N cases, prescribed 50-70 Gy to 95 % of the planning-target-volume, was assessed. For this purpose, dose distributions were recalculated using Monte Carlo, including uncertainties in PS (translation and rotation) and machine-positioning (gantry-, table-, collimator-rotation and multi-leaf collimator (MLC)). Plan robustness was evaluated by the uncertainties' impact on normal tissue complication probabilities (NTCP) for xerostomia and dysphagia and on dose-volume endpoints. Differences between DTRT and VMAT plan robustness were compared using Wilcoxon matched-pair signed-rank test ( = 5 %). Average NTCP for moderate-to-severe xerostomia and grade ≥ II dysphagia was lower for DTRT than VMAT in the nominal scenario (0.5 %, p = 0.01; 2.1 %, p < 0.01) and for all investigated uncertainties, except MLC positioning, where the difference was not significant. Average differences compared to the nominal scenario were 3.5 Gy for rotational PS ( 3°) and machine-positioning ( 2°) uncertainties, <7 Gy for translational PS uncertainties ( 5 mm) and < 20 Gy for MLC-positioning uncertainties ( 5 mm). DTRT and VMAT plan robustness to the investigated uncertainties depended on uncertainty direction and location of the structure-of-interest to the target. NTCP remained on average lower for DTRT than VMAT even when considering uncertainties.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries

Related Publications

Hannes A Loebner, and Jenny Bertholet, and Paul-Henry Mackeprang, and Werner Volken, and Olgun Elicin, and Silvan Mueller, and Gian Guyer, and Daniel M Aebersold, and Marco F M Stampanoni, and Michael K Fix, and Peter Manser
April 2022, Journal of personalized medicine,
Hannes A Loebner, and Jenny Bertholet, and Paul-Henry Mackeprang, and Werner Volken, and Olgun Elicin, and Silvan Mueller, and Gian Guyer, and Daniel M Aebersold, and Marco F M Stampanoni, and Michael K Fix, and Peter Manser
May 2010, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology,
Hannes A Loebner, and Jenny Bertholet, and Paul-Henry Mackeprang, and Werner Volken, and Olgun Elicin, and Silvan Mueller, and Gian Guyer, and Daniel M Aebersold, and Marco F M Stampanoni, and Michael K Fix, and Peter Manser
January 2016, Practical radiation oncology,
Hannes A Loebner, and Jenny Bertholet, and Paul-Henry Mackeprang, and Werner Volken, and Olgun Elicin, and Silvan Mueller, and Gian Guyer, and Daniel M Aebersold, and Marco F M Stampanoni, and Michael K Fix, and Peter Manser
November 2013, Physics in medicine and biology,
Hannes A Loebner, and Jenny Bertholet, and Paul-Henry Mackeprang, and Werner Volken, and Olgun Elicin, and Silvan Mueller, and Gian Guyer, and Daniel M Aebersold, and Marco F M Stampanoni, and Michael K Fix, and Peter Manser
January 2019, Physics and imaging in radiation oncology,
Hannes A Loebner, and Jenny Bertholet, and Paul-Henry Mackeprang, and Werner Volken, and Olgun Elicin, and Silvan Mueller, and Gian Guyer, and Daniel M Aebersold, and Marco F M Stampanoni, and Michael K Fix, and Peter Manser
February 2015, Acta oncologica (Stockholm, Sweden),
Hannes A Loebner, and Jenny Bertholet, and Paul-Henry Mackeprang, and Werner Volken, and Olgun Elicin, and Silvan Mueller, and Gian Guyer, and Daniel M Aebersold, and Marco F M Stampanoni, and Michael K Fix, and Peter Manser
March 2013, The British journal of radiology,
Hannes A Loebner, and Jenny Bertholet, and Paul-Henry Mackeprang, and Werner Volken, and Olgun Elicin, and Silvan Mueller, and Gian Guyer, and Daniel M Aebersold, and Marco F M Stampanoni, and Michael K Fix, and Peter Manser
January 2016, Journal of applied clinical medical physics,
Hannes A Loebner, and Jenny Bertholet, and Paul-Henry Mackeprang, and Werner Volken, and Olgun Elicin, and Silvan Mueller, and Gian Guyer, and Daniel M Aebersold, and Marco F M Stampanoni, and Michael K Fix, and Peter Manser
September 2017, Journal of applied clinical medical physics,
Hannes A Loebner, and Jenny Bertholet, and Paul-Henry Mackeprang, and Werner Volken, and Olgun Elicin, and Silvan Mueller, and Gian Guyer, and Daniel M Aebersold, and Marco F M Stampanoni, and Michael K Fix, and Peter Manser
November 2006, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology,
Copied contents to your clipboard!