An abnormal alpha subunit of erythrocyte spectrin has been described in hereditary pyropoikilocytosis (HPP), a rare hemolytic anemia characterized by erythrocyte budding and fragmentation. In HPP spectrin, the N terminal domain of the alpha subunit (alpha I T80) shows increased susceptibility to tryptic digestion, resulting in cleavage to a 50,000-d peptide, presumably due to a change in primary structure of the alpha I domain which alters conformation and generates the new cleavage site. The functional result of this conformational alteration is marked impairment of spectrin oligomer formation in vitro, consistent with the established role of alpha I T80 in spectrin self-association. In the present study, we demonstrate an abnormal spectrin alpha subunit in two kindreds with hereditary elliptocytosis (HE) that is qualitatively identical to HPP spectrin. Clinical expression of HE in these families ranges from mild elliptocytosis without hemolysis to severe poikilocytic hemolytic anemia clinically resembling HPP. In all affected individuals, a fraction of alpha I T80 is abnormal, as shown by its cleavage during mild tryptic digestion to the 50 kd peptide described in HPP; the fraction of alpha I T80 affected is directly proportional to the severity of clinical expression of HE. Spectrin oligomer formation is likewise impaired to a degree which correlates with hematologic disease. One of the HE kindreds studied demonstrated polymorphism in the spectrin alpha II domain, previously described as a frequent occurrence in blacks. This family also demonstrates a variant alpha III domain in spectrin that has not previously been described. We conclude that the abnormality in the alpha I domain originally described in HPP spectrin is shared by a subset of patients with HE; the severity of clinical expression, ranging from mild nonhemolytic HE to poikilocytic hemolytic anemia, is related to the fractional quantity of the alpha subunit that is affected.