Multi-institutional arrangements: relationships between governing boards and hospital chief executive officers. 1985

J Alexander, and L L Morlock

This investigation focuses on the impact of multi-institutional arrangements on the role of governing boards in limiting or enhancing the managerial autonomy of individual hospitals. Data from a 1979 Special Survey by the American Hospital Association (N = 4213) are used to examine governing board-administrator relationships as a function of the degree of autonomy and scope of responsibility of the hospital governing board. It is hypothesized that governing boards responsible for multiple hospitals or for multiple nonhospital organizations and those boards accountable to a higher organizational authority will exercise more formal control over hospital chief executive officers (CEOs) than will boards of single or autonomous hospitals. The analysis assumes that formal control by the governing board over the management function of the individual hospital is exercised partly through soliciting or limiting participation by hospital administrators in key policy decisions and through the evaluation of administrative performance. Therefore, it is anticipated that hospitals governed by boards with multiple responsibilities as well as hospitals governed by boards accountable to a higher authority will be (1) less likely to have CEOs who are members of the governing board executive committee, (2) more likely to have annual performance reviews of the CEO by the governing board, and (3) more likely to have such reviews conducted according to preestablished criteria. Study results provide general support for the hypotheses with respect to hospital boards with multiple responsibilities: the data suggest that such boards do exercise greater control over hospital administrators and these effects do appear to be stronger for hospitals in the private sector. Hospitals governed by boards accountable to a higher authority, however, are more likely to have CEOs who are members of the governing board executive committee--a pattern in direct opposition to that hypothesized. Furthermore, these boards are no more likely to conduct annual CEO performance reviews than are boards with more autonomy. Boards accountable to higher authorities are more likely, however, to use preestablished criteria when such reviews are conducted. This general pattern is similar whether hospital boards are accountable to religious authorities, to investor-owned corporate boards, or to the boards of not-for-profit multi-institutional systems. A different pattern emerges, however, for boards accountable to a state, county, or local government authority.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D007400 Interprofessional Relations The reciprocal interaction of two or more professional individuals. Etiquette, Medical,Medical Etiquette,Relations, Interprofessional
D009096 Multi-Institutional Systems Institutional systems consisting of more than one health facility which have cooperative administrative arrangements through merger, affiliation, shared services, or other collective ventures. Multi-Hospital Systems,Multi-Institutional System,Multihospital Systems,System, Multi-Hospital,System, Multi-Institutional,Systems, Multi-Institutional,Multi Hospital Systems,Multi Institutional System,Multi Institutional Systems,Multi-Hospital System,Multihospital System,System, Multi Hospital,System, Multi Institutional,System, Multihospital,Systems, Multi Institutional,Systems, Multi-Hospital,Systems, Multihospital
D009935 Organizational Affiliation Formal relationships established between otherwise independent organizations. These include affiliation agreements, interlocking boards, common controls, hospital medical school affiliations, etc. Affiliation, Organizational,Affiliations, Organizational,Organizational Affiliations
D011050 Policy Making The decision process by which individuals, groups or institutions establish policies pertaining to plans, programs or procedures. Analysis, Policy,Policy Analysis,Policy Development,Analyses, Policy,Development, Policy,Developments, Policy,Making, Policy,Policy Analyses,Policy Developments
D004650 Employee Performance Appraisal The assessment of the functioning of an employee in relation to work. Nurses Performance Evaluation,Performance Appraisal, Employee,Family Planning Personnel Evaluation,Appraisal, Employee Performance,Appraisals, Employee Performance,Employee Performance Appraisals,Evaluation, Nurses Performance,Evaluations, Nurses Performance,Nurses Performance Evaluations,Performance Appraisals, Employee,Performance Evaluation, Nurses,Performance Evaluations, Nurses
D006075 Governing Board The group in which legal authority is vested for the control of health-related institutions and organizations. Board, Governing,Boards, Governing,Governing Boards
D006270 Health Facility Administrators Managerial personnel responsible for implementing policy and directing the activities of health care facilities such as nursing homes. Administrator, Health Facility,Administrators, Health Facility,Facility Administrator, Health,Facility Administrators, Health,Health Facility Administrator
D006740 Hospital Administrators Managerial personnel responsible for implementing policy and directing the activities of hospitals. Administrator, Hospital,Administrators, Hospital,Hospital Administrator
D006779 Hospitals, Public Hospitals controlled by various types of government, i.e., city, county, district, state or federal. Public Hospitals,Hospital, Public,Public Hospital
D006788 Hospitals, Voluntary Private, not-for-profit hospitals that are autonomous, self-established, and self-supported. Hospitals, Private, Not-for-Profit,Hospitals Privates, Not-for-Profit,Not-for-Profit Hospitals Private,Not-for-Profit Hospitals Privates,Private, Not-for-Profit Hospitals,Voluntary Hospitals,Hospital, Voluntary,Hospitals Private, Not-for-Profit,Hospitals Privates, Not for Profit,Not for Profit Hospitals Private,Not for Profit Hospitals Privates,Private, Not for Profit Hospitals,Privates, Not-for-Profit Hospitals,Voluntary Hospital

Related Publications

J Alexander, and L L Morlock
January 1977, NLN publications,
J Alexander, and L L Morlock
January 1988, Modern healthcare,
J Alexander, and L L Morlock
January 1982, Hospital & health services administration,
J Alexander, and L L Morlock
August 2022, Hospital topics,
J Alexander, and L L Morlock
June 1956, Hospital progress,
J Alexander, and L L Morlock
May 1982, JAMA,
J Alexander, and L L Morlock
May 1986, The American journal of emergency medicine,
J Alexander, and L L Morlock
October 1985, The Journal of medical practice management : MPM,
Copied contents to your clipboard!