As a model of flavin-dependent biological dehydrogenation, flavin-sensitized photodehydrogenation and photodecarboxylation were studied by variation of substrate, flavin, pH and solvent. Evidence for the following rules is given. (1) When the reactive site of a photosubstrate is an alpha-carbon atom of the type CH-CO2-, decarboxylation is preferred over dehydrogenation, whereas the reverse is true for the neutral CH-CO2H. (2) Consequently these reactions do not exhibit a measurable isotope effect with C2H-CO2-, in contrast with the findings by Penzer, Radda, Taylor & Taylor [(1970) Vitam. Horm. (N.Y.) 28, 441--466], which could not be reproduced. When the substate does not contain a carboxylate group, isotope effects occur, in verification of previous reports, e.g. for benzyl alcohol C6H5-C2H20H. (3) The mechanism of flavin-sensitized substrate photodecarboxylation is assumed to consist in a primary carbanion fixation at the flavin nucleus (position 4a, 5 or 8) with concomitant liberation of CO2. This step is followed by rapid fragmentation of the adduct CH-Fl-red., provided that the substrate contains a functional and electron-donating group X, e.g. X = OH, OCH3 or NH2 (but not NH3+ !) in X CH-CO2-. (4) The minimal requirement for flavin-sensitized C-H dehydrogenation is the presence of a hydroxyl group. For example, methanol as substrate and solvent is dehydrogenated at pH sufficiently alkaline for detection of the presence of the active species CH3O-, whereas at more acidic pH substrate dehydrogenation is competing with flavin autophotolysis, which depends on the substituents in the flavin nucleus.