Comparison of automated and rapid manual methods for the same-day identification of Enterobacteriaceae. 1983

J H Jorgensen, and J E Johnson, and G A Alexander, and R Paxson, and G L Alderson

The Vitek AMS automated instrument method for identification of Enterobacteriaceae was compared with two rapid manual methods intended for the same purpose, the Micro ID System and the API 20E Same-Day procedure, on a series of 400 consecutive fresh clinical isolates. Results were compared with identifications obtained using the API 20E System with overnight incubation and supplemental tube biochemicals (when needed). Both the final (8-hour) and a manually requested, presumptive 5-hour result from the AMS were compared with the 4-hour results provided by the Micro ID and the 5-hour results provided by the API. The Micro ID system proved to be the most rapid and accurate of the three test systems by correctly identifying 96.8% (387/400) of isolates. The API 20E using 5-hour readings identified 90.7% (363/400) of isolates, although 96.8% (387/400) could be identified if supplemental overnight tests were employed to separate profile codes with "good likelihood, but low selectivity." The AMS correctly identified 88.8% (355/400) isolates after 5 hours, and 95.0% (380/400) following 8 hours incubation.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D008722 Methods A series of steps taken in order to conduct research. Techniques,Methodological Studies,Methodological Study,Procedures,Studies, Methodological,Study, Methodological,Method,Procedure,Technique
D004755 Enterobacteriaceae A family of gram-negative, facultatively anaerobic, rod-shaped bacteria that do not form endospores. Its organisms are distributed worldwide with some being saprophytes and others being plant and animal parasites. Many species are of considerable economic importance due to their pathogenic effects on agriculture and livestock. Coliform Bacilli,Enterobacteria,Ewingella,Leclercia,Paracolobactrum,Sodalis
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D001331 Automation Controlled operation of an apparatus, process, or system by mechanical or electronic devices that take the place of human organs of observation, effort, and decision. (From Webster's Collegiate Dictionary, 1993) Automations
D001431 Bacteriological Techniques Techniques used in studying bacteria. Bacteriologic Technic,Bacteriologic Technics,Bacteriologic Techniques,Bacteriological Technique,Technic, Bacteriological,Technics, Bacteriological,Technique, Bacteriological,Techniques, Bacteriological,Bacteriologic Technique,Bacteriological Technic,Bacteriological Technics,Technic, Bacteriologic,Technics, Bacteriologic,Technique, Bacteriologic,Techniques, Bacteriologic
D013997 Time Factors Elements of limited time intervals, contributing to particular results or situations. Time Series,Factor, Time,Time Factor

Related Publications

J H Jorgensen, and J E Johnson, and G A Alexander, and R Paxson, and G L Alderson
September 1982, American journal of clinical pathology,
J H Jorgensen, and J E Johnson, and G A Alexander, and R Paxson, and G L Alderson
October 1985, European journal of clinical microbiology,
J H Jorgensen, and J E Johnson, and G A Alexander, and R Paxson, and G L Alderson
December 1986, American journal of clinical pathology,
J H Jorgensen, and J E Johnson, and G A Alexander, and R Paxson, and G L Alderson
March 1983, Journal of clinical microbiology,
J H Jorgensen, and J E Johnson, and G A Alexander, and R Paxson, and G L Alderson
October 1990, Canadian journal of surgery. Journal canadien de chirurgie,
J H Jorgensen, and J E Johnson, and G A Alexander, and R Paxson, and G L Alderson
April 1982, European journal of clinical microbiology,
J H Jorgensen, and J E Johnson, and G A Alexander, and R Paxson, and G L Alderson
January 2005, Clinical microbiology reviews,
J H Jorgensen, and J E Johnson, and G A Alexander, and R Paxson, and G L Alderson
November 1990, American journal of hospital pharmacy,
J H Jorgensen, and J E Johnson, and G A Alexander, and R Paxson, and G L Alderson
September 2018, Transfusion,
J H Jorgensen, and J E Johnson, and G A Alexander, and R Paxson, and G L Alderson
January 2005, Journal of clinical laboratory analysis,
Copied contents to your clipboard!