Comparative evaluation of the Eiken and API 20E systems and conventional methods for identification of members of the family Enterobacteriaceae. 1984

C B Castillo, and D A Bruckner

To evaluate the accuracy and utility of the Eiken Systek No. 1 (Eiken system; Eiken Chemical Co., Ltd., Tokyo, Japan), we conducted a clinical comparison, with 345 Enterobacteriaceae isolates, of the Eiken System with API 20E (Analytab Products, Inc., Plainview, N.Y.) and conventional methods. The Eiken system is a 21-biochemical-test battery tray stored at 25 degrees C and inoculated in one step. It is similar to the API 20E except that the Eiken system contains malonate, adonitol, and maltose; lacks gelatin, sucrose, melibiose, amygdalin, and arabinose; and uses reagent strips instead of liquid reagents. The API 20E and Eiken systems correctly identified 339 (97.7%) and 276 (79.5%), respectively, and misidentified 3 (0.9%) and 13 (3.7%), respectively, of the isolates. There were no identification codes for 5 (1.4%) organisms with the API 20E and 58 (16.7%) organisms with the Eiken system; of these latter unidentified organisms, 42 were identified as Proteus spp., Morganella sp., and Providencia rettgeri by conventional methods. There was no significant difference between the two rapid systems in total time required for inoculation and reading. Modifications for interpretation of decarboxylase and oxidase tests were needed for the Eiken system, and manipulation of reagent strips required considerable dexterity. However, the Eiken system was easier to inoculate than the API 20E, and, with minor increases in the data base to include more of the Proteus and Morganella spp. and P. rettgeri, the system should be reliable for identification of members of the family Enterobacteriaceae.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D011933 Reagent Kits, Diagnostic Commercially prepared reagent sets, with accessory devices, containing all of the major components and literature necessary to perform one or more designated diagnostic tests or procedures. They may be for laboratory or personal use. Diagnostic Reagent Kits,Diagnostic Reagents and Test Kits,Diagnostic Test Kits,In Vitro Diagnostic Device,In Vitro Diagnostic Devices,In Vitro Diagnostic Medical Device,In Vitro Diagnostic Medical Devices,Kits, Diagnostic Reagent,Diagnostic Reagent Kit,Diagnostic Test Kit,Kit, Diagnostic Reagent,Kit, Diagnostic Test,Kits, Diagnostic Test,Reagent Kit, Diagnostic,Test Kit, Diagnostic,Test Kits, Diagnostic
D003201 Computers Programmable electronic devices designed to accept data, perform prescribed mathematical and logical operations at high speed, and display the results of these operations. Calculators, Programmable,Computer Hardware,Computers, Digital,Hardware, Computer,Calculator, Programmable,Computer,Computer, Digital,Digital Computer,Digital Computers,Programmable Calculator,Programmable Calculators
D004755 Enterobacteriaceae A family of gram-negative, facultatively anaerobic, rod-shaped bacteria that do not form endospores. Its organisms are distributed worldwide with some being saprophytes and others being plant and animal parasites. Many species are of considerable economic importance due to their pathogenic effects on agriculture and livestock. Coliform Bacilli,Enterobacteria,Ewingella,Leclercia,Paracolobactrum,Sodalis

Related Publications

C B Castillo, and D A Bruckner
January 1982, Journal of clinical microbiology,
C B Castillo, and D A Bruckner
January 1981, Journal of clinical microbiology,
C B Castillo, and D A Bruckner
June 1978, Journal of clinical microbiology,
C B Castillo, and D A Bruckner
May 1979, Journal of clinical microbiology,
C B Castillo, and D A Bruckner
December 1976, The American journal of medical technology,
C B Castillo, and D A Bruckner
January 1978, Journal of clinical pathology,
C B Castillo, and D A Bruckner
October 1985, European journal of clinical microbiology,
Copied contents to your clipboard!