In contrast to young mice, old mice fail to reject a transplanted challenge of the highly immunogenic, ultraviolet light-induced tumor 1591-RE. Old mice also fail to mount a cytolytic tumor-specific immune response in vivo, and spleen cells of old mice are defective in their ability to generate tumor-specific T cells in vitro. In the present study we report the results of cell culture mixing experiments that show that this deficiency is due to a decreased responsiveness of the Lyt-2+ tumor-specific cytolytic T cell precursors of the old animals. We also demonstrate with limiting dilution analysis that the defective responsiveness is not due to a clonal exhaustion of the precursors. In fact, the responsiveness could be restored in vitro by culturing the spleen cells of old animals at high density or by the addition of excess Lyt-1-/Lyt-2-/2000-rad-resistant spleen cells from young or old mice. Our results suggest that the rescue of tumor immunity in old individuals may be possible, perhaps by educating effector cells in vitro for adoptive immunotherapy.