Distal splenorenal shunt vs. portal-systemic shunt: current status of a controlled trial. 1981

H O Conn, and R H Resnick, and N D Grace, and C E Atterbury, and D Horst, and R J Groszmann, and P Gazmuri, and R J Gusberg, and B Thayer, and D Berk, and S C Wright, and R Vollman, and D M Tilson, and W V McDermott, and J A Cohen, and M Kerstein, and A L Toole, and J P Maselli, and S Razvi, and A Ishihara, and H Stern, and C Trey, and E T O'Hara, and W Widrich, and H Aisenberg, and H C Stansel, and M Zinny

A prospective controlled comparison of portal-systemic (PSS) and distal splenorenal shunts (DSRS) in cirrhotic patients who had survived hemorrhage from esophagogastric varices was undertaken 5 yr ago at five hospitals by the Boston-New Haven Collaborative Liver Group. The clinical and endoscopic criteria for massive hemorrhage were satisfied in 155 patients. Thirty-four patients were excluded, primarily because of uncontrolled hemorrhage. Thirty-four were rejected because the were poor operative risks and 21 because they did not satisfy criteria. Thirteen patients refused to participate; the remaining 53 were randomized; 29 to receive PSS and 24, DSRS. The two groups were similar in clinical, laboratory, and manometric characteristics. The DSRS group was older and tended to have had more previous hemorrhages. Followup ranged from 1 to 56 months (mean 21). After PSS, which was performed by 10 different surgeons, 6 patients died during the hospital admission (21%) compared to 2 after DSRS (12%). There were 6 late deaths in the PSS group and 4 in the DSRS group. Portal-systemic encephalopathy occurred in 5 of the 23 survivors of PSS (23%), and in 6 of the 19 who survived DSRS (32%. Two patients in the PSS group bled (9%), 1 after thrombosis and 1 after stenosis of the shunt. Three patients in the DSRS group bled (16%) and all had thrombosis of the shunt. PSS was associated with an unexplained but inordinately high operative mortality. Although the DSRS was accomplished with an acceptably low operative mortality, it was associated with frequent portal-systemic encephalopathy, shunt occlusion, and recurrent hemorrhage. Similar incidences of portal-systemic encephalopathy, shunt occlusion, and recurrent hemorrhage were observed in the PSS group. More patients and longer followup are necessary to determine which of these portal decompressive procedures is superior.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D008103 Liver Cirrhosis Liver disease in which the normal microcirculation, the gross vascular anatomy, and the hepatic architecture have been variably destroyed and altered with fibrous septa surrounding regenerated or regenerating parenchymal nodules. Cirrhosis, Liver,Fibrosis, Liver,Hepatic Cirrhosis,Liver Fibrosis,Cirrhosis, Hepatic
D008297 Male Males
D008875 Middle Aged An adult aged 45 - 64 years. Middle Age
D009026 Mortality All deaths reported in a given population. CFR Case Fatality Rate,Crude Death Rate,Crude Mortality Rate,Death Rate,Age Specific Death Rate,Age-Specific Death Rate,Case Fatality Rate,Decline, Mortality,Determinants, Mortality,Differential Mortality,Excess Mortality,Mortality Decline,Mortality Determinants,Mortality Rate,Mortality, Differential,Mortality, Excess,Age-Specific Death Rates,Case Fatality Rates,Crude Death Rates,Crude Mortality Rates,Death Rate, Age-Specific,Death Rate, Crude,Death Rates,Determinant, Mortality,Differential Mortalities,Excess Mortalities,Mortalities,Mortality Declines,Mortality Determinant,Mortality Rate, Crude,Mortality Rates,Rate, Age-Specific Death,Rate, Case Fatality,Rate, Crude Death,Rate, Crude Mortality,Rate, Death,Rate, Mortality,Rates, Case Fatality
D011170 Portasystemic Shunt, Surgical Surgical venous shunt between the portal and systemic circulation to effect decompression of the portal circulation. It is performed primarily in the treatment of bleeding esophageal varices resulting from portal hypertension. Types of shunt include portacaval, splenorenal, mesocaval, splenocaval, left gastric-caval (coronary-caval), portarenal, umbilicorenal, and umbilicocaval. Portosystemic Shunt, Surgical,Portasystemic Shunt,Portosystemic Shunt,Shunt, Surgical Portasystemic,Shunt, Surgical Portosystemic,Surgical Portasystemic Shunt,Surgical Portosystemic Shunt,Portasystemic Shunts,Portasystemic Shunts, Surgical,Portosystemic Shunts,Portosystemic Shunts, Surgical,Shunt, Portasystemic,Shunt, Portosystemic,Shunts, Portasystemic,Shunts, Portosystemic,Shunts, Surgical Portasystemic,Shunts, Surgical Portosystemic,Surgical Portasystemic Shunts,Surgical Portosystemic Shunts
D011183 Postoperative Complications Pathologic processes that affect patients after a surgical procedure. They may or may not be related to the disease for which the surgery was done, and they may or may not be direct results of the surgery. Complication, Postoperative,Complications, Postoperative,Postoperative Complication
D011446 Prospective Studies Observation of a population for a sufficient number of persons over a sufficient number of years to generate incidence or mortality rates subsequent to the selection of the study group. Prospective Study,Studies, Prospective,Study, Prospective
D002986 Clinical Trials as Topic Works about pre-planned studies of the safety, efficacy, or optimum dosage schedule (if appropriate) of one or more diagnostic, therapeutic, or prophylactic drugs, devices, or techniques selected according to predetermined criteria of eligibility and observed for predefined evidence of favorable and unfavorable effects. This concept includes clinical trials conducted both in the U.S. and in other countries. Clinical Trial as Topic
D004932 Esophageal and Gastric Varices Dilated blood vessels in the ESOPHAGUS or GASTRIC FUNDUS that shunt blood from the portal circulation (PORTAL SYSTEM) to the systemic venous circulation. Often they are observed in individuals with portal hypertension (HYPERTENSION, PORTAL). Esophageal Varices,Gastric Varices,Esophageal Varix,Gastric Varix,Varices, Esophageal,Varices, Gastric,Varix, Esophageal,Varix, Gastric
D005260 Female Females

Related Publications

H O Conn, and R H Resnick, and N D Grace, and C E Atterbury, and D Horst, and R J Groszmann, and P Gazmuri, and R J Gusberg, and B Thayer, and D Berk, and S C Wright, and R Vollman, and D M Tilson, and W V McDermott, and J A Cohen, and M Kerstein, and A L Toole, and J P Maselli, and S Razvi, and A Ishihara, and H Stern, and C Trey, and E T O'Hara, and W Widrich, and H Aisenberg, and H C Stansel, and M Zinny
August 1983, Seminars in liver disease,
H O Conn, and R H Resnick, and N D Grace, and C E Atterbury, and D Horst, and R J Groszmann, and P Gazmuri, and R J Gusberg, and B Thayer, and D Berk, and S C Wright, and R Vollman, and D M Tilson, and W V McDermott, and J A Cohen, and M Kerstein, and A L Toole, and J P Maselli, and S Razvi, and A Ishihara, and H Stern, and C Trey, and E T O'Hara, and W Widrich, and H Aisenberg, and H C Stansel, and M Zinny
September 1978, Annals of surgery,
H O Conn, and R H Resnick, and N D Grace, and C E Atterbury, and D Horst, and R J Groszmann, and P Gazmuri, and R J Gusberg, and B Thayer, and D Berk, and S C Wright, and R Vollman, and D M Tilson, and W V McDermott, and J A Cohen, and M Kerstein, and A L Toole, and J P Maselli, and S Razvi, and A Ishihara, and H Stern, and C Trey, and E T O'Hara, and W Widrich, and H Aisenberg, and H C Stansel, and M Zinny
January 1981, Annales chirurgiae et gynaecologiae,
H O Conn, and R H Resnick, and N D Grace, and C E Atterbury, and D Horst, and R J Groszmann, and P Gazmuri, and R J Gusberg, and B Thayer, and D Berk, and S C Wright, and R Vollman, and D M Tilson, and W V McDermott, and J A Cohen, and M Kerstein, and A L Toole, and J P Maselli, and S Razvi, and A Ishihara, and H Stern, and C Trey, and E T O'Hara, and W Widrich, and H Aisenberg, and H C Stansel, and M Zinny
July 1990, American journal of surgery,
H O Conn, and R H Resnick, and N D Grace, and C E Atterbury, and D Horst, and R J Groszmann, and P Gazmuri, and R J Gusberg, and B Thayer, and D Berk, and S C Wright, and R Vollman, and D M Tilson, and W V McDermott, and J A Cohen, and M Kerstein, and A L Toole, and J P Maselli, and S Razvi, and A Ishihara, and H Stern, and C Trey, and E T O'Hara, and W Widrich, and H Aisenberg, and H C Stansel, and M Zinny
August 1972, Annals of surgery,
H O Conn, and R H Resnick, and N D Grace, and C E Atterbury, and D Horst, and R J Groszmann, and P Gazmuri, and R J Gusberg, and B Thayer, and D Berk, and S C Wright, and R Vollman, and D M Tilson, and W V McDermott, and J A Cohen, and M Kerstein, and A L Toole, and J P Maselli, and S Razvi, and A Ishihara, and H Stern, and C Trey, and E T O'Hara, and W Widrich, and H Aisenberg, and H C Stansel, and M Zinny
January 1987, Hepatology (Baltimore, Md.),
H O Conn, and R H Resnick, and N D Grace, and C E Atterbury, and D Horst, and R J Groszmann, and P Gazmuri, and R J Gusberg, and B Thayer, and D Berk, and S C Wright, and R Vollman, and D M Tilson, and W V McDermott, and J A Cohen, and M Kerstein, and A L Toole, and J P Maselli, and S Razvi, and A Ishihara, and H Stern, and C Trey, and E T O'Hara, and W Widrich, and H Aisenberg, and H C Stansel, and M Zinny
May 2006, Gastroenterology,
H O Conn, and R H Resnick, and N D Grace, and C E Atterbury, and D Horst, and R J Groszmann, and P Gazmuri, and R J Gusberg, and B Thayer, and D Berk, and S C Wright, and R Vollman, and D M Tilson, and W V McDermott, and J A Cohen, and M Kerstein, and A L Toole, and J P Maselli, and S Razvi, and A Ishihara, and H Stern, and C Trey, and E T O'Hara, and W Widrich, and H Aisenberg, and H C Stansel, and M Zinny
March 2008, Journal of hepatology,
H O Conn, and R H Resnick, and N D Grace, and C E Atterbury, and D Horst, and R J Groszmann, and P Gazmuri, and R J Gusberg, and B Thayer, and D Berk, and S C Wright, and R Vollman, and D M Tilson, and W V McDermott, and J A Cohen, and M Kerstein, and A L Toole, and J P Maselli, and S Razvi, and A Ishihara, and H Stern, and C Trey, and E T O'Hara, and W Widrich, and H Aisenberg, and H C Stansel, and M Zinny
November 1975, Canadian journal of surgery. Journal canadien de chirurgie,
H O Conn, and R H Resnick, and N D Grace, and C E Atterbury, and D Horst, and R J Groszmann, and P Gazmuri, and R J Gusberg, and B Thayer, and D Berk, and S C Wright, and R Vollman, and D M Tilson, and W V McDermott, and J A Cohen, and M Kerstein, and A L Toole, and J P Maselli, and S Razvi, and A Ishihara, and H Stern, and C Trey, and E T O'Hara, and W Widrich, and H Aisenberg, and H C Stansel, and M Zinny
July 1982, Archives of surgery (Chicago, Ill. : 1960),
Copied contents to your clipboard!