Medical students' attitude towards psychiatry: a ten-year comparison. 1982

A M Ghadirian, and F Engelsmann

Medical students' interest in and attitudes toward psychiatry, both as a field of education and as a medical specialty, have been explored by a number of investigators. The present study compares two series of investigations completed at the McGill University teaching hospitals over a ten year span and involving third year medical students in 1968-69 (n = 59) and in 1978-79 (n = 168). The findings of these two studies are evaluated in two parts: (1) comparison of attitudes toward psychiatry before and after clinical training in 1978-79. (2) comparison of the results obtained in 1969 with those in 1979. The results of the comparison showed that students currently put more emphasis on the clinical aspects of psychiatric training and less on the theoretical and research aspects of psychiatry. Thirty-two percent of students in 1979 found psychotherapy to be the most useful treatment modality as compared with only 10 percent on 1969. Findings reflecting the usefulness of organic therapies in psychiatry remained fairly consistent, but behaviour therapy was found to be less useful by students in 1979 than in 1969. In the 1969 survey, 2 per cent of the third year students indicated an interest in psychiatry as a future career as compared with 3.3 per cent in 1979. The implications of these findings are discussed in relation to the psychiatric training programmes in medical schools.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D008297 Male Males
D011570 Psychiatry The medical science that deals with the origin, diagnosis, prevention, and treatment of mental disorders.
D011792 Quebec A province of eastern Canada. Its capital is Quebec. The region belonged to France from 1627 to 1763 when it was lost to the British. The name is from the Algonquian quilibek meaning the place where waters narrow, referring to the gradually narrowing channel of the St. Lawrence or to the narrows of the river at Cape Diamond. (From Webster's New Geographical Dictionary, 1988, p993 & Room, Brewer's Dictionary of Names, 1992, p440)
D002321 Career Choice Selection of a type of occupation or profession. Career Choices,Choice, Career,Choices, Career
D004504 Education, Medical, Undergraduate The period of medical education in a medical school. In the United States it follows the baccalaureate degree and precedes the granting of the M.D. Medical Education, Undergraduate,Education, Undergraduate Medical,Undergraduate Medical Education
D005260 Female Females
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D001291 Attitude of Health Personnel Attitudes of personnel toward their patients, other professionals, toward the medical care system, etc. Staff Attitude,Attitude, Staff,Attitudes, Staff,Health Personnel Attitude,Health Personnel Attitudes,Staff Attitudes
D001523 Mental Disorders Psychiatric illness or diseases manifested by breakdowns in the adaptational process expressed primarily as abnormalities of thought, feeling, and behavior producing either distress or impairment of function. Mental Illness,Psychiatric Diseases,Psychiatric Disorders,Psychiatric Illness,Behavior Disorders,Diagnosis, Psychiatric,Mental Disorders, Severe,Psychiatric Diagnosis,Illness, Mental,Mental Disorder,Mental Disorder, Severe,Mental Illnesses,Psychiatric Disease,Psychiatric Disorder,Psychiatric Illnesses,Severe Mental Disorder,Severe Mental Disorders
D013337 Students, Medical Individuals enrolled in a school of medicine or a formal educational program in medicine. Medical Student,Medical Students,Student, Medical

Related Publications

A M Ghadirian, and F Engelsmann
December 1988, Canadian journal of psychiatry. Revue canadienne de psychiatrie,
A M Ghadirian, and F Engelsmann
October 2012, Journal of the Indian Medical Association,
A M Ghadirian, and F Engelsmann
January 1992, Medical education,
A M Ghadirian, and F Engelsmann
May 2023, Scientific reports,
A M Ghadirian, and F Engelsmann
August 2008, Annals of general psychiatry,
A M Ghadirian, and F Engelsmann
January 2008, Journal of Ayub Medical College, Abbottabad : JAMC,
A M Ghadirian, and F Engelsmann
January 2002, Education for health (Abingdon, England),
A M Ghadirian, and F Engelsmann
October 1993, Indian journal of psychiatry,
A M Ghadirian, and F Engelsmann
September 2011, Zhong nan da xue xue bao. Yi xue ban = Journal of Central South University. Medical sciences,
Copied contents to your clipboard!