Respective contribution of orientation contrast and illusion of self-tilt to the rod-and-frame effect. 1995

C Cian, and D Esquivié, and P A Barraud, and C Raphel
Centre de Recherches, Service de Santé des Armées Emile Parde, La Tronche, France.

The visual angle subtended by the frame seems to be an important determinant of the contribution of orientation contrast and illusion of self-tilt (ie vection) to the rod-and-frame effect. Indeed, the visuovestibular factor (which produces vection) seems to be predominant in large displays and the contrast effect in small displays. To determine how these two phenomena are combined to account for the rod-and-frame effect, independent estimates of the magnitude of each component in relation to the angular size subtended by the display were examined. Thirty-five observers were exposed to three sets of experimental situations: body-adjustment test (illusion of self-tilt only), the tilt illusion (contrast only) and the rod-and-frame test, each display subtending 7, 12, 28, and 45 deg of visual angle. Results showed that errors recorded in the three situations increased linearly with the angular size. Whatever the size of the frame, both mechanisms, contrast effect (tilt illusion) and illusory effect on self-orientation (body-adjustment test), are always present. However, rod-and-frame errors became greater at a faster rate than the other two effects as the size of teh stimuli became larger. Neither one nor the other independent phenomenen, nor the combined effect could fully account for the rod-and-frame effect whatever the angular size of the apparatus.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D007699 Kinesthesis Sense of movement of a part of the body, such as movement of fingers, elbows, knees, limbs, or weights. Kinesthesia,Kinesthetic Sense,Movement Sensation,Kinestheses,Kinesthesias,Kinesthetic Senses,Movement Sensations
D008297 Male Males
D009903 Optical Illusions An illusion of vision usually affecting spatial relations. Illusion, Optical,Illusions, Optical,Optical Illusion
D009949 Orientation Awareness of oneself in relation to time, place and person. Cognitive Orientation,Mental Orientation,Psychological Orientation,Cognitive Orientations,Mental Orientations,Orientation, Cognitive,Orientation, Mental,Orientation, Psychological,Orientations,Orientations, Cognitive,Orientations, Mental,Orientations, Psychological,Psychological Orientations
D010364 Pattern Recognition, Visual Mental process to visually perceive a critical number of facts (the pattern), such as characters, shapes, displays, or designs. Recognition, Visual Pattern,Visual Pattern Recognition
D011187 Posture The position or physical attitude of the body. Postures
D011601 Psychophysics The science dealing with the correlation of the physical characteristics of a stimulus, e.g., frequency or intensity, with the response to the stimulus, in order to assess the psychologic factors involved in the relationship. Psychophysic
D004193 Discrimination Learning Learning that is manifested in the ability to respond differentially to various stimuli. Discriminative Learning,Discrimination Learnings,Discriminative Learnings,Learning, Discrimination,Learning, Discriminative
D004856 Postural Balance A POSTURE in which an ideal body mass distribution is achieved. Postural balance provides the body carriage stability and conditions for normal functions in stationary position or in movement, such as sitting, standing, or walking. Postural Control,Posture Balance,Posture Control,Posture Equilibrium,Balance, Postural,Musculoskeletal Equilibrium,Postural Equilibrium,Balance, Posture,Control, Postural,Control, Posture,Equilibrium, Musculoskeletal,Equilibrium, Postural,Equilibrium, Posture,Postural Controls,Posture Balances,Posture Controls,Posture Equilibriums
D005260 Female Females

Related Publications

C Cian, and D Esquivié, and P A Barraud, and C Raphel
April 2019, Journal of vision,
C Cian, and D Esquivié, and P A Barraud, and C Raphel
May 1979, Perception & psychophysics,
C Cian, and D Esquivié, and P A Barraud, and C Raphel
January 1974, Perception,
C Cian, and D Esquivié, and P A Barraud, and C Raphel
March 1986, Perception & psychophysics,
C Cian, and D Esquivié, and P A Barraud, and C Raphel
January 1997, Perception,
C Cian, and D Esquivié, and P A Barraud, and C Raphel
January 1977, Perception,
C Cian, and D Esquivié, and P A Barraud, and C Raphel
January 1989, Perception,
C Cian, and D Esquivié, and P A Barraud, and C Raphel
April 1981, Perception & psychophysics,
C Cian, and D Esquivié, and P A Barraud, and C Raphel
February 2006, Psychonomic bulletin & review,
C Cian, and D Esquivié, and P A Barraud, and C Raphel
June 1977, Perceptual and motor skills,
Copied contents to your clipboard!