Connexins form a variety of gap junction channels that vary in their developmental and tissue-specific levels of expression, modulation of gating by transjunctional voltage and posttranslational modification, and unitary channel conductance (gamma j). Despite a 10-fold variation in gamma j, whether connexin-specific channels possess distinct ionic and molecular permeabilities is presently unknown. A major assumption of the conventional model for a gap junction channel pore is that gamma j is determined primarily by pore diameter. Hence, molecular size permeability limits should increase and ionic selectivity should decrease with increasing channel gamma j (and pore diameter). Equimolar ion substitution of 120 mmol/L KCl for potassium glutamate was used to determine the unitary conductance ratios for rat connexin40 and connexin43, chicken connexin43 and connexin45, and human connexin37 channels functionally expressed in communication-deficient mouse neuroblastoma (N2A) cells. Comparison of experimental and predicted conductance ratios based on the aqueous mobilities of all ions according to the Goldman-Hodgkin-Katz current equation was used to determine relative anion-to-cation permeability ratios. Direct correlation of junctional conductance with dye transfer of two fluorescein-derivatives (2 mmol/L 6-carboxyfluorescein or 2',7'-dichlorofluorescein) was also performed. Both approaches revealed a range of selectivities and permeabilities for all five different connexins that was independent of channel conductance. These results are not consistent with the conventional simple aqueous pore model of a gap junction channel and suggest a new model for connexin channel conductance and permselectivity based on electrostatic interactions. Divergent conductance and permeability properties are features of other classes of ion channels (eg, Na+ and K+ channels), implying similar mechanisms for selectivity.