Ethical reasoning and decision-making in the clinical setting: assessing the process. 1995

C Myser, and I H Kerridge, and K R Mitchell
Faculty of Medicine, University of Newcastle, Australia.

Clinical ethical reasoning and analysis are skills as central to good patient care as the efficient application of biomedical knowledge to diagnosis and prognosis. However, experience in teaching clinical ethics to senior medical students has indicated that simply trying to 'apply' the knowledge learnt about ethical theories, principles, concepts and rules in the clinical setting does not ensure ethical competence in clinical decision-making. In 1992, we developed and piloted a three-session programme that focused on a more systematic approach to the way students identified and attempted to manage ethical issues in their clinical practice. This programme was modified and improved in 1993 and further expanded in 1994. Our experience suggests that many students are now better able to bridge what has been called the 'gap' between the possession of ethical knowledge and its actual use in clinical decision-making. The remaining problem was assessment. How do you assess clinical ethical reasoning and decision-making? In the preclinical years of medical education, knowledge-based assessment tools, like the modified essay question (MEQ), provide a means for assessing the sensitivity of students to ethical issues. However, such tools permit neither an appraisal of how students actually make clinical ethical decisions, nor which factors students perceive as important in making an actual clinical decision. In order to make this type of appraisal, we developed a format for a written case report that facilitated our assessing the process as well as the end-product, the decision.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D003657 Decision Making The process of making a selective intellectual judgment when presented with several complex alternatives consisting of several variables, and usually defining a course of action or an idea. Credit Assignment,Assignment, Credit,Assignments, Credit,Credit Assignments
D004504 Education, Medical, Undergraduate The period of medical education in a medical school. In the United States it follows the baccalaureate degree and precedes the granting of the M.D. Medical Education, Undergraduate,Education, Undergraduate Medical,Undergraduate Medical Education
D004992 Ethics, Medical The principles of professional conduct concerning the rights and duties of the physician, relations with patients and fellow practitioners, as well as actions of the physician in patient care and interpersonal relations with patient families. Medical Ethics
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D001315 Australia The smallest continent and an independent country, comprising six states and two territories. Its capital is Canberra. Canton and Enderbury Islands,Christmas Island,Christmas Island (Australia)
D013337 Students, Medical Individuals enrolled in a school of medicine or a formal educational program in medicine. Medical Student,Medical Students,Student, Medical
D013663 Teaching A formal and organized process of transmitting knowledge to a person or group. Teaching Method,Training Activity,Training Technique,Academic Training,Educational Technics,Educational Techniques,Pedagogy,Teaching Methods,Technics, Educational,Techniques, Educational,Training Activities,Training Technics,Training Techniques,Activities, Training,Activity, Training,Educational Technic,Educational Technique,Method, Teaching,Methods, Teaching,Pedagogies,Technic, Educational,Technic, Training,Technics, Training,Technique, Educational,Technique, Training,Techniques, Training,Training Technic,Training, Academic
D013850 Thinking Mental activity that is not predominantly perceptual by which one apprehends some aspect of an object or situation based on past learning and experience. Critical Thinking,Thinking Skills,Thought,Thinking Skill,Thinking, Critical,Thoughts
D015510 Clinical Medicine The study and practice of medicine by direct examination of the patient. Medicine, Clinical

Related Publications

C Myser, and I H Kerridge, and K R Mitchell
December 2009, Medical education,
C Myser, and I H Kerridge, and K R Mitchell
June 1986, Perioperative nursing quarterly,
C Myser, and I H Kerridge, and K R Mitchell
January 1993, AWHONN's clinical issues in perinatal and women's health nursing,
C Myser, and I H Kerridge, and K R Mitchell
January 2009, Journal of obstetric, gynecologic, and neonatal nursing : JOGNN,
C Myser, and I H Kerridge, and K R Mitchell
December 2006, Best practice & research. Clinical anaesthesiology,
C Myser, and I H Kerridge, and K R Mitchell
August 1990, Neonatal network : NN,
C Myser, and I H Kerridge, and K R Mitchell
January 1980, American Nurses Association Publications,
C Myser, and I H Kerridge, and K R Mitchell
May 2000, Social work,
C Myser, and I H Kerridge, and K R Mitchell
August 2002, Ohio nurses review,
C Myser, and I H Kerridge, and K R Mitchell
December 1990, Journal of the South Carolina Medical Association (1975),
Copied contents to your clipboard!