The enzyme collagenase (EC 3.4.24.7), a key mediator in biological remodeling, can be induced in early-passage fibroblasts by a wide variety of agents and conditions. In contrast, at least some primary tissue fibroblasts are incompetent to synthesize collagenase in response to many of these stimulators. In this study, we investigate mechanisms controlling response to two of the conditions in question: (i) trypsin or cytochalasin B, which disrupt actin stress fibers, or (ii) phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate (PMA), which activates growth factor signaling pathways. We demonstrate that collagenase expression stimulated by trypsin or cytochalasin B is regulated entirely through an autocrine cytokine, interleukin 1 alpha (IL-1 alpha). The IL-1 alpha intermediate also constitutes the major mechanism by which PMA stimulates collagenase expression, although a second signaling pathway(s) contributes to a minor extent. Elevation of the IL-1 alpha level in response to stimulators is found to be sustained by means of an autocrine feedback loop in early-passage fibroblast cultures. In contrast, fibroblasts freshly isolated from the tissue are incompetent to activate and sustain the IL-1 alpha feedback loop, even though they synthesize collagenase in response to exogenous IL-1. We conclude that this is the reason why tissue fibroblasts are limited, in comparison with subcultured fibroblasts, in their capacity to synthesize collagenase. Activation of the IL-1 alpha feedback loop, therefore, seems likely to be an important mechanism by which resident tissue cells adopt the remodeling phenotype.