[Comparative study of the recovery phase. Laparoscopic cholecystectomy following isoflurane, methohexital and propofol anesthesia]. 1994

M Blobner, and H J Schneck, and A R Felber, and S Goegler, and H Feussner, and S Jelen-Esselborn
Institut für Anaesthesiologie, Technischen Universität München.

Total intravenous anaesthesia (TIVA) is increasingly used in short-stay surgery such as laparoscopic cholecystectomy. TIVA may provide fast recovery of psychomotor function, thus being of benefit to both the patient's behaviour and postoperative management. The purpose of this prospective study was to compare postoperative recovery from TIVA using propofol or methohexitone as the hypnotic component and balanced anaesthesia with isoflurane. PATIENTS AND METHODS. After giving informed consent and approval by the ethical committee of our hospital, 51 patients (ASA I, II) were investigated in a prospective study. Patients were randomised to receive either isoflurane, methohexitone, or propofol. Perioperative management with regard to premedication, intraoperative analgesia, relaxation, ventilation, and postoperative analgesia was carried out identically for all groups. Postoperative vigilance, pain, and nausea scores were assessed 15, 30, 60, 120, and 360 min after extubation with a visual analogue scale (VAS). At the same points, psychomotor recovery was investigated with the following assays: sedation as shown in Table 1; orientation with ten questions as to person, time, and location; memory as expressed by the patient's ability to repeat five words; a calculation test with five subtractions of the number 7 beginning from 100; and word generation by the number of words with an initial "m" given within 1 min and with animal names. Data were analysed with Kruskal Wallis' test for multiple comparisons between the groups and with Friedman's test for repeated measurements. All values are given as medians (interquartile range) or ranges. RESULTS. There was no difference between the groups' physical condition (Table 2). All intraoperative parameters compared well between groups; the management of anaesthesia was smoother with isoflurane than with the other anaesthetics. Psychomotor recovery was somewhat faster in the propofol group than the methohexitone group, as indicated by sedation score, orientation, memory and calculation tests (Table 4), word generation tests (Fig. 4), and subjective vigilance score (Fig. 3). The difference in recovery time between the propofol and isoflurane groups was minimal and without any significance or relevance. The incidence of postoperative nausea was significantly lower after balanced anaesthesia with isoflurane (24%, P < 0.05) as compared to TIVA with either propofol (53%) or methohexitone (41%). However, there were only minor differences between the groups; the ability to cooperate and be mobilised was not limited. DISCUSSION. Each of the three techniques used in this study is suitable for anaesthesia in patients undergoing laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Since fast recovery of vigilance and psychomotor function is very important in outpatient surgery, opioid-supplemented propofol anaesthesia is well established. Inhalation anaesthesia with isoflurane in air/oxygen without adding nitrous oxide compares well to propofol TIVA for laparoscopic surgery.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D007530 Isoflurane A stable, non-explosive inhalation anesthetic, relatively free from significant side effects.
D008297 Male Males
D008568 Memory Complex mental function having four distinct phases: (1) memorizing or learning, (2) retention, (3) recall, and (4) recognition. Clinically, it is usually subdivided into immediate, recent, and remote memory.
D008723 Methohexital An intravenous anesthetic with a short duration of action that may be used for induction of anesthesia. Methohexitone,Brevimytal Natrium,Brevital,Brietal,Brietal-Sodium,Methohexital Sodium,Methohexital, Monosodium Salt,Brietal Sodium,Monosodium Salt Methohexital,Natrium, Brevimytal,Sodium, Methohexital
D008875 Middle Aged An adult aged 45 - 64 years. Middle Age
D011184 Postoperative Period The period following a surgical operation. Period, Postoperative,Periods, Postoperative,Postoperative Periods
D011446 Prospective Studies Observation of a population for a sufficient number of persons over a sufficient number of years to generate incidence or mortality rates subsequent to the selection of the study group. Prospective Study,Studies, Prospective,Study, Prospective
D011597 Psychomotor Performance The coordination of a sensory or ideational (cognitive) process and a motor activity. Perceptual Motor Performance,Sensory Motor Performance,Visual Motor Coordination,Coordination, Visual Motor,Coordinations, Visual Motor,Motor Coordination, Visual,Motor Coordinations, Visual,Motor Performance, Perceptual,Motor Performance, Sensory,Motor Performances, Perceptual,Motor Performances, Sensory,Perceptual Motor Performances,Performance, Perceptual Motor,Performance, Psychomotor,Performance, Sensory Motor,Performances, Perceptual Motor,Performances, Psychomotor,Performances, Sensory Motor,Psychomotor Performances,Sensory Motor Performances,Visual Motor Coordinations
D002763 Cholecystectomy Surgical removal of the GALLBLADDER. Cholecystectomies
D005260 Female Females

Related Publications

M Blobner, and H J Schneck, and A R Felber, and S Goegler, and H Feussner, and S Jelen-Esselborn
June 2008, Journal of the College of Physicians and Surgeons--Pakistan : JCPSP,
M Blobner, and H J Schneck, and A R Felber, and S Goegler, and H Feussner, and S Jelen-Esselborn
January 1987, Cahiers d'anesthesiologie,
M Blobner, and H J Schneck, and A R Felber, and S Goegler, and H Feussner, and S Jelen-Esselborn
October 2007, Middle East journal of anaesthesiology,
M Blobner, and H J Schneck, and A R Felber, and S Goegler, and H Feussner, and S Jelen-Esselborn
March 1997, Acta anaesthesiologica Scandinavica,
M Blobner, and H J Schneck, and A R Felber, and S Goegler, and H Feussner, and S Jelen-Esselborn
April 1992, Der Anaesthesist,
M Blobner, and H J Schneck, and A R Felber, and S Goegler, and H Feussner, and S Jelen-Esselborn
January 1993, Cahiers d'anesthesiologie,
M Blobner, and H J Schneck, and A R Felber, and S Goegler, and H Feussner, and S Jelen-Esselborn
June 1994, Acta anaesthesiologica Sinica,
M Blobner, and H J Schneck, and A R Felber, and S Goegler, and H Feussner, and S Jelen-Esselborn
September 1993, Der Anaesthesist,
M Blobner, and H J Schneck, and A R Felber, and S Goegler, and H Feussner, and S Jelen-Esselborn
November 1987, Agressologie: revue internationale de physio-biologie et de pharmacologie appliquees aux effets de l'agression,
M Blobner, and H J Schneck, and A R Felber, and S Goegler, and H Feussner, and S Jelen-Esselborn
December 1998, Anesthesiology,
Copied contents to your clipboard!