The purpose of this study was to compare the reliabilities of two methods of measuring finger circumference. Traditionally, finger circumference is determined clinically by the use of a tape measure. In this study, a tape-measure device for recording finger circumference utilizing a torque meter was compared with the traditional method to determine reliability differences. Ninety-two occupational therapists and occupational therapy students obtained circumferential measurements of the author's left index finger at the middle of the proximal phalanx utilizing the two methods. The readings obtained for each method were analyzed to determine the coefficient of variation and to compare their variances. The coefficient of variation for the traditional method was 2.92 and for the device utilizing the torque meter was 0.75. The F ratio was 15.63, which is significant at the 0.01 level. The results of this study indicate greater interrater reliability using a device that can accurately measure torque and allow the therapist to control the amount of tension applied when obtaining circumferential measurements using a tape measure.