The activation of factor XI initiates the intrinsic coagulation pathway. Until recently it was believed that the main activator of factor XI is factor XIIa in conjunction with the cofactor high molecular weight kininogen on a negatively charged surface. Two recent reports have presented evidence that in a purified system factor XI is activatable by thrombin together with the soluble polyanion dextran sulfate. To assess the physiological relevance of these findings we studied the activation of factor XI in normal and factor XII-deficient plasma. We used either kaolin/cephalin or dextran sulfate as a surface for the intrinsic coagulation pathway, tissue factor to generate thrombin via the extrinsic pathway, or the addition of alpha-thrombin directly. 125I-factor XI, added to factor XI-deficient plasma at physiologic concentrations (35 nmol/L), is rapidly cleaved on incubation with kaolin. The kinetics appear to be exponential with half the maximum cleavage at 5 minutes. Similar kinetics of factor XI cleavage are seen when 40 nmol/L factor XIIa (equal to 10% of factor XII activation) is added to factor XII-deficient plasma if an activating surface is provided. Tissue factor (1:500) added to plasma did not induce cleavage of factor XI during a 90-minute incubation, although fibrin formation within 30 seconds indicated that thrombin was generated via the extrinsic pathway. Adding 1 mumol/L alpha-thrombin (equivalent to 50% prothrombin activation) directly to factor XII deficient or normal plasma (with or without kaolin/cephalin/Ca2+ or dextran sulfate) led to instantaneous fibrinogen cleavage, but again no cleavage of factor XI was observable. We conclude that in plasma surroundings factor XI is not activated by thrombin, and that proposals of thrombin initiation of the intrinsic coagulation cascade are not supportable.