Macrophage scavenger receptors have been implicated in the development of atherosclerosis and other macrophage-associated functions, including host defense. The mechanism by which these receptors bind a wide array of polyanions, such as acetylated low density lipoprotein (Ac-LDL), with high affinity has not yet been elucidated; however, it has been proposed that the positively charged extracellular collagenous domain of scavenger receptors plays a key role in ligand binding. To test this proposal, we generated truncation mutants of the bovine and murine scavenger receptors and studied their expression in transiently transfected COS cells. These mutants contain only 8 (bovine) or 5 (murine) of the 24 Gly-X-Y tripeptide repeats found in the collagenous domains of the full-length receptors. Immunochemical analyses established that the truncation of the bovine scavenger receptor did not interfere significantly with its synthesis, trimerization, post-translational processing, intracellular transport, surface expression, or stability. However, unlike their full-length counterparts, the truncated bovine and murine receptors were unable to bind Ac-LDL. Thus, the collagenous domain was necessary for normal ligand binding. In addition, cotransfection of the expression vector for the truncated bovine scavenger receptor with that for the full-length receptor resulted in dramatically reduced activity of the full-length construct (dominant negative effect). A ligand bead-binding assay was used to show that the isolated collagenous domain from a different protein, complement component C1q, could bind a wide variety of polyanions with a specificity which was similar, but not identical, to that of scavenger receptors. These results suggest that the collagenous domain of the scavenger receptor is both necessary and sufficient to determine the broad binding specificity that characterizes this unusual receptor. Scavenger receptors and C1q, along with the mannose-binding protein, conglutinin, and lung surfactant apoprotein A, help define a set of proteins which all contain short collagenous domains and which all appear to participate in host defense. Their short collagenous domains may contribute significantly to their host-defense functions.