The hepatotoxicity of acetaminophen is believed to be mediated by the reactive metabolite N-acetyl-p-benzoquinone imine; however, the mechanism by which this metabolite produces the toxicity is unknown. The metabolite, which is both an electrophile and an oxidizing agent, may covalently bind to critical proteins, or it may initiate oxidative damage. We have previously developed a Western blot assay for detection of acetaminophen covalently bound to protein and have reported the relationship between covalent binding and the development of hepatotoxicity. Recently, we developed a Western blot assay for protein aldehyde formation, which may occur via the reactive oxygen species, the hydroxyl radical. In this paper, we have compared covalent binding to protein aldehyde formation. Toxic doses of acetaminophen (400 mg/kg) were administered to mice, and the mice were subsequently killed at 0, 1, 2, 4, and 6 h. Since the oxidizing agent FeSO4 has been reported to potentiate lipid peroxidation when administered with acetaminophen, other mice received FeSO4 (100 mg/kg) plus acetaminophen. Compared to saline-treated control mice, acetaminophen treatment significantly increased serum alanine aminotransferase levels, an index of hepatotoxicity, at 4 and 6 h, but not at 1 or 2 h. Acetaminophen plus FeSO4 treatment of mice significantly increased serum alanine aminotransferase levels at 2, 4, and 6 h compared to controls. Levels of alanine aminotransferase in serum of acetaminophen plus ferrous sulfate-treated mice were higher at 4 and 6 h than those of acetaminophen-treated mice, but not significantly different. FeSO4 alone did not increase alanine aminotransferase levels. Western blot assays revealed that acetaminophen did not cause an increase in protein aldehydes over control at any time, nor did acetaminophen plus FeSO4; however, FeSO4 alone increased the intensity of staining of the immunoblot for protein aldehydes over control at all times after 0 time. Acetaminophen-protein adducts were detected in acetaminophen- and acetaminophen plus FeSO4-treated mice. In vitro experiments indicated that FeSO4 plus tert-butyl hydroperoxide in the presence of bovine serum albumin increased protein aldehyde formation. Inclusion of acetaminophen in the incubation mixture inhibited protein oxidation of bovine serum albumin in a concentration dependent manner. The data indicate that acetaminophen quenches protein oxidation, presumably by reacting with the hydroxyl radical. These data are consistent with the theory that acetaminophen covalent binding is the primary mechanism of toxicity and argue against a role for protein oxidation in acetaminophen hepatotoxicity.