Can low-level 50/60 Hz electric and magnetic fields cause biological effects? 1997

P A Valberg, and R Kavet, and C N Rafferty
Gradient Corporation, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138, USA.

Some epidemiological studies have suggested that exposure to ambient, low-level 50/60 Hz electric and magnetic fields (EMFs) increases risk of disease. Whether this association has a causal basis depends in part on whether the electrical, chemical and mechanical "signals" induced within living cells by ambient EMFs are detectable in the complex milieu of voltages, currents and forces present within the living organism. Magnetic responsiveness has been found in some animals and bacteria; aquatic animals (e.g. sharks and rays) can sense weak electric fields. We outline the physics of several mechanisms by which EMFs may interact: (1) Energy transfer by acceleration of ions and charged proteins modifies cell membranes and receptor proteins; however, EMF energies are far below those typical of biomolecules in the cell. (2) Electric fields induced inside the body exert force on electric charges and electric moments; however, these forces are considerably smaller than typical biological forces. (3) The magnetic moments of ferromagnetic particles and free radical molecules interact with magnetic fields, but magnetic-moment sensory cells have not been found in humans, and modification of radical recombination rates by EMFs in a biological system is highly problematic. (4) Resonant interactions involve EMFs driving vibrational or orbital transitions in ion-biomolecule complexes; these mechanisms conflict with accepted physics, and many experimental tests have not found the predicted effects. (5) Temporal averaging or spatial summation can improve the ratio of "signal" to "noise" in any system, but this "mechanism" requires biological structures and neural processes having the necessary capabilities of EMF detection and temporal averaging that have not been found in humans. In summary, biological effects in humans due to extremely low-frequency EMFs of the order of those found in residential environments [< or = 2 microT (< or = 20 mG)] are implausible based on current understanding of physics and biology. Biological effects in humans at higher fields [> 10 microT (> 100 mG)] might reach plausibility as a result of time-averaging in combination with a magnetic-moment transduction mechanism; but even here, neither specialized EMF transduction structures nor appropriate averaging networks have been demonstrated. The bypothesis that the epidemiological associations observed between 50/60 Hz EMFs and disease reflect a causal relationship is not supported by what is known about mechanisms.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D007477 Ions An atom or group of atoms that have a positive or negative electric charge due to a gain (negative charge) or loss (positive charge) of one or more electrons. Atoms with a positive charge are known as CATIONS; those with a negative charge are ANIONS.
D002468 Cell Physiological Phenomena Cellular processes, properties, and characteristics. Cell Physiological Processes,Cell Physiology,Cell Physiological Phenomenon,Cell Physiological Process,Physiology, Cell,Phenomena, Cell Physiological,Phenomenon, Cell Physiological,Physiological Process, Cell,Physiological Processes, Cell,Process, Cell Physiological,Processes, Cell Physiological
D002477 Cells The fundamental, structural, and functional units or subunits of living organisms. They are composed of CYTOPLASM containing various ORGANELLES and a CELL MEMBRANE boundary. Cell
D004560 Electricity The physical effects involving the presence of electric charges at rest and in motion.
D004563 Electrochemistry The study of chemical changes resulting from electrical action and electrical activity resulting from chemical changes. Electrochemistries
D004574 Electromagnetic Fields Fields representing the joint interplay of electric and magnetic forces. Electromagnetic Field,Field, Electromagnetic,Fields, Electromagnetic
D004735 Energy Transfer The transfer of energy of a given form among different scales of motion. (From McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms, 6th ed). It includes the transfer of kinetic energy and the transfer of chemical energy. The transfer of chemical energy from one molecule to another depends on proximity of molecules so it is often used as in techniques to measure distance such as the use of FORSTER RESONANCE ENERGY TRANSFER. Transfer, Energy
D005609 Free Radicals Highly reactive molecules with an unsatisfied electron valence pair. Free radicals are produced in both normal and pathological processes. Free radicals include reactive oxygen and nitrogen species (RONS). They are proven or suspected agents of tissue damage in a wide variety of circumstances including radiation, damage from environment chemicals, and aging. Natural and pharmacological prevention of free radical damage is being actively investigated. Free Radical
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000818 Animals Unicellular or multicellular, heterotrophic organisms, that have sensation and the power of voluntary movement. Under the older five kingdom paradigm, Animalia was one of the kingdoms. Under the modern three domain model, Animalia represents one of the many groups in the domain EUKARYOTA. Animal,Metazoa,Animalia

Related Publications

P A Valberg, and R Kavet, and C N Rafferty
April 1998, Mutation research,
P A Valberg, and R Kavet, and C N Rafferty
June 2019, Toxicology and industrial health,
P A Valberg, and R Kavet, and C N Rafferty
March 1990, Australasian physical & engineering sciences in medicine,
P A Valberg, and R Kavet, and C N Rafferty
February 2019, eLife,
P A Valberg, and R Kavet, and C N Rafferty
July 2002, Physics in medicine and biology,
P A Valberg, and R Kavet, and C N Rafferty
January 1997, Epidemiologic reviews,
P A Valberg, and R Kavet, and C N Rafferty
December 1996, Scandinavian journal of work, environment & health,
P A Valberg, and R Kavet, and C N Rafferty
January 1987, Bioelectromagnetics,
P A Valberg, and R Kavet, and C N Rafferty
January 1993, Bioelectromagnetics,
P A Valberg, and R Kavet, and C N Rafferty
January 1989, Bioelectromagnetics,
Copied contents to your clipboard!