Biomaterial Database

Histologic/histochemical grading system for osteoarthritic articular cartilage: reproducibility and validity. 1997

K Ostergaard, and J Petersen, and C B Andersen, and K Bendtzen, and D M Salter

National University Hospital/Rigshospitalet, Copenhagen, Denmark.

OBJECTIVE To evaluate the reproducibility and validity of the histologic/histochemical grading system (HHGS) for osteoarthritis (OA) developed by Mankin and coworkers. METHODS Sections of human articular cartilage from macroscopically normal and osteoarthritic femoral heads were graded by the HHGS (0-14 scale) twice by 3 observers, and intra- and interobserver reproducibility was determined. RESULTS The exact intra- and interobserver reproducibilities ranged from 22% to 33% and from 13% to 25%, respectively. Intra- and interobserver variation ranged from -7 to 5. Although scores were generally higher in cartilage from osteoarthritic joints as compared with cartilage from normal joints, the difference reached statistical significance for only 2 observers. Additionally, the average scores from all observers were within the definitive range for OA (>5) in 30% of sections from normal joints, and in only 47% of sections from OA joints. CONCLUSIONS The results indicate that the reproducibility and the validity of the HHGS are inadequate, and an improved histopathologic grading system for OA is needed.

UI	MeSH Term	Description	Entries
D008297	Male		Males
D008875	Middle Aged	An adult aged 45 - 64 years.	Middle Age
D010003	Osteoarthritis	A progressive, degenerative joint disease, the most common form of arthritis, especially in older persons. The disease is thought to result not from the aging process but from biochemical changes and biomechanical stresses affecting articular cartilage. In the foreign literature it is often called osteoarthrosis deformans.	Arthritis, Degenerative,Osteoarthrosis,Osteoarthrosis Deformans,Arthroses,Arthrosis,Arthritides, Degenerative,Degenerative Arthritides,Degenerative Arthritis,Osteoarthritides,Osteoarthroses
D012016	Reference Values	The range or frequency distribution of a measurement in a population (of organisms, organs or things) that has not been selected for the presence of disease or abnormality.	Normal Range,Normal Values,Reference Ranges,Normal Ranges,Normal Value,Range, Normal,Range, Reference,Ranges, Normal,Ranges, Reference,Reference Range,Reference Value,Value, Normal,Value, Reference,Values, Normal,Values, Reference
D002358	Cartilage, Articular	A protective layer of firm, flexible cartilage over the articulating ends of bones. It provides a smooth surface for joint movement, protecting the ends of long bones from wear at points of contact.	Articular Cartilage,Articular Cartilages,Cartilages, Articular
D005069	Evaluation Studies as Topic	Works about studies that determine the effectiveness or value of processes, personnel, and equipment, or the material on conducting such studies.	Critique,Evaluation Indexes,Evaluation Methodology,Evaluation Report,Evaluation Research,Methodology, Evaluation,Pre-Post Tests,Qualitative Evaluation,Quantitative Evaluation,Theoretical Effectiveness,Use-Effectiveness,Critiques,Effectiveness, Theoretical,Evaluation Methodologies,Evaluation Reports,Evaluation, Qualitative,Evaluation, Quantitative,Evaluations, Qualitative,Evaluations, Quantitative,Indexes, Evaluation,Methodologies, Evaluation,Pre Post Tests,Pre-Post Test,Qualitative Evaluations,Quantitative Evaluations,Report, Evaluation,Reports, Evaluation,Research, Evaluation,Test, Pre-Post,Tests, Pre-Post,Use Effectiveness
D005260	Female		Females
D005270	Femur Head	The hemispheric articular surface at the upper extremity of the thigh bone. (Stedman, 26th ed)	Femoral Head,Femoral Heads,Femur Heads,Head, Femoral,Head, Femur
D006651	Histocytochemistry	Study of intracellular distribution of chemicals, reaction sites, enzymes, etc., by means of staining reactions, radioactive isotope uptake, selective metal distribution in electron microscopy, or other methods.	Cytochemistry
D006801	Humans	Members of the species Homo sapiens.	Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man