Do recorded doses overestimate true doses received by Chernobyl cleanup workers? Results of cytogenetic analyses of Estonian workers by fluorescence in situ hybridization. 1998

L G Littlefield, and A F McFee, and S I Salomaa, and J D Tucker, and P D Inskip, and A M Sayer, and C Lindholm, and S Mäkinen, and R Mustonen, and K Sorensen, and M Tekkel, and T Veidebaum, and A Auvinen, and J D Boice
Oak Ridge Institute for Science and Education, Tennessee 37830, USA.

Studies of workers who were sent to Chernobyl after the 1986 reactor accident are being conducted to provide a better understanding of the effects of chronic low-dose radiation exposures. A crucial component to these investigations is an accurate assessment of the radiation doses received during the cleanup activities. To provide information on biological measurements of dose, fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) with whole-chromosome painting probes has been applied to quantify stable chromosome aberrations (translocations and insertions) among a defined cohort of 4,833 cleanup workers from Estonia. Cytogenetic analysis of 48-h lymphocyte cultures from 118 Estonian cleanup workers (10.3 cGy mean recorded dose; 25 cGy maximum), 29 Estonian population controls and 21 American controls was conducted by three laboratories. More than 258,000 painted metaphases were evaluated. Overall, we observed lower translocation frequencies than has been reported in previous studies using FISH among Chernobyl cleanup workers. In our data, a clear association with increased levels of translocations was seen with increasing age at blood drawing. There was no correlation, however, between aberration frequency and recorded measurements of physical dose or any category of potential high-dose and high-dose-rate exposure such as being sent to Chernobyl in 1986, working on the roof near the damaged nuclear reactor, working in special zones or having multiple tours. In fact, the translocation frequency was lower among the exposed workers than the controls, though not significantly so. To estimate the level of effect that would have been expected in a population of men having an average dose of approximately 10 cGy, blood from six donors was exposed to low-LET radiation, and more than 32,000 metaphases were scored to estimate dose-response coefficients for radiation-induced translocations in chromosome pairs 1, 2 and 4. Based on these results, we estimate that had this group of 118 men received an average whole-body dose of 10-11 cGy, as chronic or acute exposures, an increase in the mean frequency of chromosome translocations of more than 40-65% would have been observed in their lymphocytes compared to findings in nonirradiated controls. In spite of evaluating more than a quarter of a million metaphases, we were unable to detect any increase in the mean, median or range in chromosome aberrations in lymphocyte cultures from a group of Estonian men who took part in the cleanup of the Chernobyl nuclear power site and those who did not. We conclude that it is likely that recorded doses for these cleanup workers overestimate their average bone marrow doses, perhaps substantially. These results are consistent with several negative studies of cancer incidence in Chernobyl cleanup workers and, if borne out, suggest that future studies may not be sufficiently powerful to detect increases in leukemia or cancer, much less distinguish differences between the effects of chronic compared to brief radiation exposures.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D008214 Lymphocytes White blood cells formed in the body's lymphoid tissue. The nucleus is round or ovoid with coarse, irregularly clumped chromatin while the cytoplasm is typically pale blue with azurophilic (if any) granules. Most lymphocytes can be classified as either T or B (with subpopulations of each), or NATURAL KILLER CELLS. Lymphoid Cells,Cell, Lymphoid,Cells, Lymphoid,Lymphocyte,Lymphoid Cell
D008875 Middle Aged An adult aged 45 - 64 years. Middle Age
D011210 Power Plants Units that convert some other form of energy into electrical energy. Electric Power Plants,Hydroelectric Power Plants,Thermoelectric Power Plants,Electric Power Plant,Hydroelectric Power Plant,Plant, Electric Power,Plant, Hydroelectric Power,Plant, Power,Plant, Thermoelectric Power,Plants, Electric Power,Plants, Hydroelectric Power,Plants, Power,Plants, Thermoelectric Power,Power Plant,Power Plant, Electric,Power Plant, Hydroelectric,Power Plant, Thermoelectric,Power Plants, Electric,Power Plants, Hydroelectric,Power Plants, Thermoelectric,Thermoelectric Power Plant
D011829 Radiation Dosage The amount of radiation energy that is deposited in a unit mass of material, such as tissues of plants or animal. In RADIOTHERAPY, radiation dosage is expressed in gray units (Gy). In RADIOLOGIC HEALTH, the dosage is expressed by the product of absorbed dose (Gy) and quality factor (a function of linear energy transfer), and is called radiation dose equivalent in sievert units (Sv). Sievert Units,Dosage, Radiation,Gray Units,Gy Radiation,Sv Radiation Dose Equivalent,Dosages, Radiation,Radiation Dosages,Units, Gray,Units, Sievert
D012044 Regression Analysis Procedures for finding the mathematical function which best describes the relationship between a dependent variable and one or more independent variables. In linear regression (see LINEAR MODELS) the relationship is constrained to be a straight line and LEAST-SQUARES ANALYSIS is used to determine the best fit. In logistic regression (see LOGISTIC MODELS) the dependent variable is qualitative rather than continuously variable and LIKELIHOOD FUNCTIONS are used to find the best relationship. In multiple regression, the dependent variable is considered to depend on more than a single independent variable. Regression Diagnostics,Statistical Regression,Analysis, Regression,Analyses, Regression,Diagnostics, Regression,Regression Analyses,Regression, Statistical,Regressions, Statistical,Statistical Regressions
D004307 Dose-Response Relationship, Radiation The relationship between the dose of administered radiation and the response of the organism or tissue to the radiation. Dose Response Relationship, Radiation,Dose-Response Relationships, Radiation,Radiation Dose-Response Relationship,Radiation Dose-Response Relationships,Relationship, Radiation Dose-Response,Relationships, Radiation Dose-Response
D004957 Estonia A country in Eastern Europe, bordering the Baltic Sea and Gulf of Finland, between Latvia and Russia. The capital is Tallinn.
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D000328 Adult A person having attained full growth or maturity. Adults are of 19 through 44 years of age. For a person between 19 and 24 years of age, YOUNG ADULT is available. Adults
D012907 Smoking Willful or deliberate act of inhaling and exhaling SMOKE from burning substances or agents held by hand. Smoking Behaviors,Smoking Habit,Behavior, Smoking,Behaviors, Smoking,Habit, Smoking,Habits, Smoking,Smoking Behavior,Smoking Habits

Related Publications

L G Littlefield, and A F McFee, and S I Salomaa, and J D Tucker, and P D Inskip, and A M Sayer, and C Lindholm, and S Mäkinen, and R Mustonen, and K Sorensen, and M Tekkel, and T Veidebaum, and A Auvinen, and J D Boice
May 2003, Radiation research,
L G Littlefield, and A F McFee, and S I Salomaa, and J D Tucker, and P D Inskip, and A M Sayer, and C Lindholm, and S Mäkinen, and R Mustonen, and K Sorensen, and M Tekkel, and T Veidebaum, and A Auvinen, and J D Boice
May 1997, Radiation research,
L G Littlefield, and A F McFee, and S I Salomaa, and J D Tucker, and P D Inskip, and A M Sayer, and C Lindholm, and S Mäkinen, and R Mustonen, and K Sorensen, and M Tekkel, and T Veidebaum, and A Auvinen, and J D Boice
January 2013, Methods in molecular biology (Clifton, N.J.),
L G Littlefield, and A F McFee, and S I Salomaa, and J D Tucker, and P D Inskip, and A M Sayer, and C Lindholm, and S Mäkinen, and R Mustonen, and K Sorensen, and M Tekkel, and T Veidebaum, and A Auvinen, and J D Boice
May 1997, Radiation research,
L G Littlefield, and A F McFee, and S I Salomaa, and J D Tucker, and P D Inskip, and A M Sayer, and C Lindholm, and S Mäkinen, and R Mustonen, and K Sorensen, and M Tekkel, and T Veidebaum, and A Auvinen, and J D Boice
March 2001, Radiation research,
L G Littlefield, and A F McFee, and S I Salomaa, and J D Tucker, and P D Inskip, and A M Sayer, and C Lindholm, and S Mäkinen, and R Mustonen, and K Sorensen, and M Tekkel, and T Veidebaum, and A Auvinen, and J D Boice
May 2014, BMJ open,
L G Littlefield, and A F McFee, and S I Salomaa, and J D Tucker, and P D Inskip, and A M Sayer, and C Lindholm, and S Mäkinen, and R Mustonen, and K Sorensen, and M Tekkel, and T Veidebaum, and A Auvinen, and J D Boice
February 1998, Cancer genetics and cytogenetics,
L G Littlefield, and A F McFee, and S I Salomaa, and J D Tucker, and P D Inskip, and A M Sayer, and C Lindholm, and S Mäkinen, and R Mustonen, and K Sorensen, and M Tekkel, and T Veidebaum, and A Auvinen, and J D Boice
April 2002, Cancer genetics and cytogenetics,
L G Littlefield, and A F McFee, and S I Salomaa, and J D Tucker, and P D Inskip, and A M Sayer, and C Lindholm, and S Mäkinen, and R Mustonen, and K Sorensen, and M Tekkel, and T Veidebaum, and A Auvinen, and J D Boice
May 2019, Radiation and environmental biophysics,
L G Littlefield, and A F McFee, and S I Salomaa, and J D Tucker, and P D Inskip, and A M Sayer, and C Lindholm, and S Mäkinen, and R Mustonen, and K Sorensen, and M Tekkel, and T Veidebaum, and A Auvinen, and J D Boice
September 1995, International journal of urology : official journal of the Japanese Urological Association,
Copied contents to your clipboard!