The molecular mechanisms governing the coupling selectivity of G protein-coupled receptors activated by peptide ligands are not well understood. To shed light on this issue, we have used the Gq/11-linked V1a and the Gs-coupled V2 vasopressin peptide receptors as model systems. To explore the structural basis underlying the ability of the V2 receptor to selectively recognize Gs, we systematically substituted distinct V2 receptor segments (or single amino acids) into the V1a receptor and studied whether the resulting hybrid receptors gained the ability to mediate hormone-dependent cAMP production. This strategy appeared particularly attractive since hormone stimulation of the V1a receptor has virtually no effect on intracellular cAMP levels. Functional analysis of a large number of mutant receptors transiently expressed in COS-7 cells indicated that the presence of V2 receptor sequence at the N terminus of the third intracellular loop is critical for efficient activation of Gs. More detailed mutational analysis of this receptor region showed that two polar V2 receptor residues, Gln225 and Glu231, play key roles in Gs recognition. In addition, a short sequence at the N terminus of the cytoplasmic tail was found to make an important contribution to V2 receptor/Gs coupling selectivity. We also made the novel observation that the efficiency of V2 receptor/Gs coupling can be modulated by the length of the central portion of the third intracellular loop (rather than the specific amino acid sequence within this domain). These findings provide novel insights into the molecular mechanisms regulating peptide receptor/G protein coupling selectivity.