-transparent.png){kind=logo}
OBJECTIVE The aim of this study was to compare the validity of two direct screening questionnaires, the CAGE and MAST, in the detection of hazardous alcohol consumption with a disguised assessment by using the Trauma Scale in a poststratified general hospital sample. METHODS Surgical and medical inpatients (N = 1,379) completed the three questionnaires. Hazardous alcohol consumption was defined by criteria derived from a World Health Organization study and assessed using self-reported quantity and frequency. RESULTS The sensitivity of the Trauma Scale was not significantly different compared to the CAGE and MAST, whereas the direct questionnaires were higher in specificity and overall accuracy (p < .0001). In male surgical patients the detection rate of the Trauma Scale was higher compared to the CAGE (p < .05). Thirteen percent of subjects with hazardous levels of alcohol consumption were detected by the Trauma Scale only. In female surgical patients, the Trauma Scale, when used as an additional tool, does not improve the detection of hazardous drinkers. CONCLUSIONS Because of the low specificity, indirect assessment using a history of trauma cannot be recommended as a screening instrument in a general hospital setting. Despite a high number of false positives, the Trauma Scale may serve as an additional tool in conjunction with direct questionnaires when high sensitivity is desired.
H J Rumpf, and
U Hapke, and
A Erfurth, and
U John
January 1989,
The American journal of drug and alcohol abuse,
H J Rumpf, and
U Hapke, and
A Erfurth, and
U John
March 2001,
The British journal of general practice : the journal of the Royal College of General Practitioners,
H J Rumpf, and
U Hapke, and
A Erfurth, and
U John
September 2013,
Alcohol (Fayetteville, N.Y.),
H J Rumpf, and
U Hapke, and
A Erfurth, and
U John
October 2001,
The Australian and New Zealand journal of psychiatry,
H J Rumpf, and
U Hapke, and
A Erfurth, and
U John
September 2019,
Journal of geriatric oncology,
H J Rumpf, and
U Hapke, and
A Erfurth, and
U John
January 2022,
Current medicinal chemistry,
H J Rumpf, and
U Hapke, and
A Erfurth, and
U John
July 2017,
The European journal of health economics : HEPAC : health economics in prevention and care,
H J Rumpf, and
U Hapke, and
A Erfurth, and
U John
June 2017,
Toxicology letters,
H J Rumpf, and
U Hapke, and
A Erfurth, and
U John
August 2012,
International journal of STD & AIDS,
H J Rumpf, and
U Hapke, and
A Erfurth, and
U John
September 1994,
Canadian family physician Medecin de famille canadien,
