The CO2 hydration activities of cloned human carbonic anhydrase II (carbonate hydro-lyase, EC 4.2.1.1) and variants with Lys, Glu, Gln or Ala replacing His at sequence position 64 have been measured in a variety of different buffers in the pH range 6-9. The variants with Lys-64, Gln-64 and Ala-64 showed non-Michaelis-Menten behavior under some conditions, apparent substrate inhibition being prominent near pH 9. However, asymptotic Michaelis-Menten parameters could be estimated for the limit of low substrate concentrations. All variants show distinct buffer specificities, and imidazole derivatives, Ches and phosphate buffers yield higher kcat values that Bicine, Taps and Mops buffers under otherwise similar conditions. These results are interpreted in terms of different pathways for a rate-limiting proton transfer. In unmodified enzyme, the very high catalytic activity depends on His-64 functioning as an efficient proton transfer group, but this pathway is not available in the variants with Gln-64 and Ala-64. Imidazoles, Ches and phosphate are thought to participate in a metal center-to-buffer proton transfer pathway, whereas Bicine, Taps, Mops and Mes appear to lack this capacity, so that the rate-limiting proton transfer occurs in a metal center-to-bulk water pathway for these variants. The Lys-64 and Glu-64 variants give significantly higher kcat values in Taps, Mops and Mes buffers than the Ala-64 and Gln-64 variants. The pH dependencies of these kcat values are compatible with the hypothesis that Lys-64 and Glu-64 can function as proton transfer groups. Thus, at pH near 9, Lys-64 appears to be only 5-times less efficient than His-64, while Glu-64 is inefficient. At pH 6, Lys-64 is an inefficient proton transfer group, but Glu-64 is only 2-3-times less efficient than His-64. The data indicate that Lys-64 and Glu-64 have pKa values near 8 and below 6, respectively.