A ring-based compensator IMRT system optimized for low- and middle-income countries: Design and treatment planning study. 2018

Jonathon Van Schelt, and Daniel L Smith, and Nicholas Fong, and Dolla Toomeh, and Patricia A Sponseller, and Derek W Brown, and Meghan W Macomber, and Nina A Mayr, and Shilpen Patel, and Adam Shulman, and G V Subrahmanyam, and K N Govindarajan, and Eric C Ford
Department of Radiation Oncology, University of Washington Medical Center, Seattle, WA, 98195, USA.

OBJECTIVE We propose a novel compensator-based IMRT system designed to provide a simple, reliable, and cost-effective adjunct technology, with the goal of expanding global access to advanced radiotherapy techniques. The system would employ easily reusable tungsten bead compensators that operate independent of a gantry (e.g., mounted in a ring around the patient). Thereby the system can be retrofitted to existing linac and cobalt teletherapy units. This study explores the quality of treatment plans from the proposed system and the dependence on associated design parameters. METHODS We considered 60 Co-based plans as the most challenging scenario for dosimetry and benchmarked them against clinical MLC-based plans delivered on a linac. Treatment planning was performed in the Pinnacle treatment planning system with commissioning based on Monte Carlo simulations of compensated beams. 60 Co-compensator IMRT plans were generated for five patients with head-and-neck cancer and five with gynecological cancer and compared to respective IMRT plans using a 6 MV linac beam with an MLC. The dependence of dosimetric endpoints on compensator resolution, thickness, position, and number of beams was assessed. Dosimetric accuracy was validated by Monte Carlo simulations of dose distribution in a water phantom from beams with the IMRT plan compensators. RESULTS The 60 Co-compensator plans had on average equivalent PTV coverage and somewhat inferior OAR sparing compared to the 6 MV-MLC plans, but the differences in dosimetric endpoints were clinically acceptable. Calculated treatment times for head-and-neck plans were 7.6 ± 2.0 min vs 3.9 ± 0.8 min (6 MV-MLC vs 60 Co-compensator) and for gynecological plans were 8.7 ± 3.1 min vs 4.3 ± 0.4 min. Plan quality was insensitive to most design parameters over much of the ranges studied, with no degradation found when the compensator resolution was finer than 6 mm, maximum thickness at least 2 tenth-value-layers, and more than five beams were used. Source-to-compensator distances of 53 and 63 cm resulted in very similar plan quality. Monte Carlo simulations suggest no increase in surface dose for the geometries considered here. Simulated dosimetric validation tests had median gamma pass rates of 97.6% for criteria of 3% (global)/3 mm with a 10% threshold. CONCLUSIONS The novel ring-compensator IMRT system can produce plans of comparable quality to standard 6 MV-MLC systems. Even when 60 Co beams are used the plan quality is acceptable and treatment times are substantially reduced. 60 Co-compensator IMRT plans are adequately modeled in an existing commercial treatment planning system. These results motivate further development of this low-cost adaptable technology with translation through clinical trials and deployment to expand the reach of IMRT in low- and middle-income countries.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D009010 Monte Carlo Method In statistics, a technique for numerically approximating the solution of a mathematical problem by studying the distribution of some random variable, often generated by a computer. The name alludes to the randomness characteristic of the games of chance played at the gambling casinos in Monte Carlo. (From Random House Unabridged Dictionary, 2d ed, 1993) Method, Monte Carlo
D011874 Radiometry The measurement of radiation by photography, as in x-ray film and film badge, by Geiger-Mueller tube, and by SCINTILLATION COUNTING. Geiger-Mueller Counters,Nuclear Track Detection,Radiation Dosimetry,Dosimetry, Radiation,Geiger Counter,Geiger-Mueller Counter Tube,Geiger-Mueller Probe,Geiger-Mueller Tube,Radiation Counter,Counter Tube, Geiger-Mueller,Counter Tubes, Geiger-Mueller,Counter, Geiger,Counter, Radiation,Counters, Geiger,Counters, Geiger-Mueller,Counters, Radiation,Detection, Nuclear Track,Dosimetries, Radiation,Geiger Counters,Geiger Mueller Counter Tube,Geiger Mueller Counters,Geiger Mueller Probe,Geiger Mueller Tube,Geiger-Mueller Counter Tubes,Geiger-Mueller Probes,Geiger-Mueller Tubes,Probe, Geiger-Mueller,Probes, Geiger-Mueller,Radiation Counters,Radiation Dosimetries,Tube, Geiger-Mueller,Tube, Geiger-Mueller Counter,Tubes, Geiger-Mueller,Tubes, Geiger-Mueller Counter
D011879 Radiotherapy Dosage The total amount of radiation absorbed by tissues as a result of radiotherapy. Dosage, Radiotherapy,Dosages, Radiotherapy,Radiotherapy Dosages
D011880 Radiotherapy Planning, Computer-Assisted Computer-assisted mathematical calculations of beam angles, intensities of radiation, and duration of irradiation in radiotherapy. Computer-Assisted Radiotherapy Planning,Dosimetry Calculations, Computer-Assisted,Planning, Computer-Assisted Radiotherapy,Calculation, Computer-Assisted Dosimetry,Calculations, Computer-Assisted Dosimetry,Computer Assisted Radiotherapy Planning,Computer-Assisted Dosimetry Calculation,Computer-Assisted Dosimetry Calculations,Dosimetry Calculation, Computer-Assisted,Dosimetry Calculations, Computer Assisted,Planning, Computer Assisted Radiotherapy,Radiotherapy Planning, Computer Assisted
D003362 Cost-Benefit Analysis A method of comparing the cost of a program with its expected benefits in dollars (or other currency). The benefit-to-cost ratio is a measure of total return expected per unit of money spent. This analysis generally excludes consideration of factors that are not measured ultimately in economic terms. In contrast a cost effectiveness in general compares cost with qualitative outcomes. Cost and Benefit,Cost-Benefit Data,Benefits and Costs,Cost Benefit,Cost Benefit Analysis,Cost-Utility Analysis,Costs and Benefits,Economic Evaluation,Marginal Analysis,Analyses, Cost Benefit,Analysis, Cost Benefit,Analysis, Cost-Benefit,Analysis, Cost-Utility,Analysis, Marginal,Benefit and Cost,Cost Benefit Analyses,Cost Benefit Data,Cost Utility Analysis,Cost-Benefit Analyses,Cost-Utility Analyses,Data, Cost-Benefit,Economic Evaluations,Evaluation, Economic,Marginal Analyses
D003906 Developing Countries Countries in the process of change with economic growth, that is, an increase in production, per capita consumption, and income. The process of economic growth involves better utilization of natural and human resources, which results in a change in the social, political, and economic structures. LMICs,Less-Developed Countries,Low Income Countries,Low and Middle Income Countries,Lower-Middle-Income Country,Middle Income Countries,Third-World Countries,Under-Developed Countries,Developing Nations,Least Developed Countries,Less-Developed Nations,Third-World Nations,Under-Developed Nations,Countries, Middle Income,Countries, Third-World,Country, Least Developed,Country, Less-Developed,Country, Low Income,Country, Lower-Middle-Income,Country, Middle Income,Country, Third-World,Country, Under-Developed,Developed Country, Least,Developing Country,Developing Nation,Least Developed Country,Less Developed Countries,Less Developed Nations,Less-Developed Country,Less-Developed Nation,Low Income Country,Lower Middle Income Country,Lower-Middle-Income Countries,Middle Income Country,Nation, Less-Developed,Nation, Third-World,Nation, Under-Developed,Third World Countries,Third World Nations,Third-World Country,Third-World Nation,Under Developed Countries,Under Developed Nations,Under-Developed Country,Under-Developed Nation
D004867 Equipment Design Methods and patterns of fabricating machines and related hardware. Design, Equipment,Device Design,Medical Device Design,Design, Medical Device,Designs, Medical Device,Device Design, Medical,Device Designs, Medical,Medical Device Designs,Design, Device,Designs, Device,Designs, Equipment,Device Designs,Equipment Designs
D050397 Radiotherapy, Intensity-Modulated CONFORMAL RADIOTHERAPY that combines several intensity-modulated beams to provide improved dose homogeneity and highly conformal dose distributions. Helical Tomotherapy,Intensity-Modulated Arc Therapy,Volumetric-Modulated Arc Therapy,Arc Therapies, Intensity-Modulated,Arc Therapies, Volumetric-Modulated,Arc Therapy, Intensity-Modulated,Arc Therapy, Volumetric-Modulated,Helical Tomotherapies,Intensity Modulated Arc Therapy,Intensity-Modulated Arc Therapies,Intensity-Modulated Radiotherapies,Intensity-Modulated Radiotherapy,Radiotherapies, Intensity-Modulated,Radiotherapy, Intensity Modulated,Therapies, Intensity-Modulated Arc,Therapies, Volumetric-Modulated Arc,Therapy, Intensity-Modulated Arc,Therapy, Volumetric-Modulated Arc,Tomotherapies, Helical,Tomotherapy, Helical,Volumetric Modulated Arc Therapy,Volumetric-Modulated Arc Therapies

Related Publications

Jonathon Van Schelt, and Daniel L Smith, and Nicholas Fong, and Dolla Toomeh, and Patricia A Sponseller, and Derek W Brown, and Meghan W Macomber, and Nina A Mayr, and Shilpen Patel, and Adam Shulman, and G V Subrahmanyam, and K N Govindarajan, and Eric C Ford
February 2021, Physica medica : PM : an international journal devoted to the applications of physics to medicine and biology : official journal of the Italian Association of Biomedical Physics (AIFB),
Jonathon Van Schelt, and Daniel L Smith, and Nicholas Fong, and Dolla Toomeh, and Patricia A Sponseller, and Derek W Brown, and Meghan W Macomber, and Nina A Mayr, and Shilpen Patel, and Adam Shulman, and G V Subrahmanyam, and K N Govindarajan, and Eric C Ford
March 2011, Journal of applied clinical medical physics,
Jonathon Van Schelt, and Daniel L Smith, and Nicholas Fong, and Dolla Toomeh, and Patricia A Sponseller, and Derek W Brown, and Meghan W Macomber, and Nina A Mayr, and Shilpen Patel, and Adam Shulman, and G V Subrahmanyam, and K N Govindarajan, and Eric C Ford
January 2020, African journal of emergency medicine : Revue africaine de la medecine d'urgence,
Jonathon Van Schelt, and Daniel L Smith, and Nicholas Fong, and Dolla Toomeh, and Patricia A Sponseller, and Derek W Brown, and Meghan W Macomber, and Nina A Mayr, and Shilpen Patel, and Adam Shulman, and G V Subrahmanyam, and K N Govindarajan, and Eric C Ford
February 2023, Physica medica : PM : an international journal devoted to the applications of physics to medicine and biology : official journal of the Italian Association of Biomedical Physics (AIFB),
Jonathon Van Schelt, and Daniel L Smith, and Nicholas Fong, and Dolla Toomeh, and Patricia A Sponseller, and Derek W Brown, and Meghan W Macomber, and Nina A Mayr, and Shilpen Patel, and Adam Shulman, and G V Subrahmanyam, and K N Govindarajan, and Eric C Ford
January 2011, Medical dosimetry : official journal of the American Association of Medical Dosimetrists,
Jonathon Van Schelt, and Daniel L Smith, and Nicholas Fong, and Dolla Toomeh, and Patricia A Sponseller, and Derek W Brown, and Meghan W Macomber, and Nina A Mayr, and Shilpen Patel, and Adam Shulman, and G V Subrahmanyam, and K N Govindarajan, and Eric C Ford
April 2010, Journal of the ICRU,
Jonathon Van Schelt, and Daniel L Smith, and Nicholas Fong, and Dolla Toomeh, and Patricia A Sponseller, and Derek W Brown, and Meghan W Macomber, and Nina A Mayr, and Shilpen Patel, and Adam Shulman, and G V Subrahmanyam, and K N Govindarajan, and Eric C Ford
May 2003, Medical physics,
Jonathon Van Schelt, and Daniel L Smith, and Nicholas Fong, and Dolla Toomeh, and Patricia A Sponseller, and Derek W Brown, and Meghan W Macomber, and Nina A Mayr, and Shilpen Patel, and Adam Shulman, and G V Subrahmanyam, and K N Govindarajan, and Eric C Ford
July 2023, Medical physics,
Jonathon Van Schelt, and Daniel L Smith, and Nicholas Fong, and Dolla Toomeh, and Patricia A Sponseller, and Derek W Brown, and Meghan W Macomber, and Nina A Mayr, and Shilpen Patel, and Adam Shulman, and G V Subrahmanyam, and K N Govindarajan, and Eric C Ford
June 2023, Global health, science and practice,
Jonathon Van Schelt, and Daniel L Smith, and Nicholas Fong, and Dolla Toomeh, and Patricia A Sponseller, and Derek W Brown, and Meghan W Macomber, and Nina A Mayr, and Shilpen Patel, and Adam Shulman, and G V Subrahmanyam, and K N Govindarajan, and Eric C Ford
April 2019, The Lancet. Child & adolescent health,
Copied contents to your clipboard!