Probabilistic risk assessment of mine-derived copper in the Ok Tedi/Fly River, Papua New Guinea. 2022

David A Spadaro, and Josh King, and Brad Angel, and Kitty S McKnight, and Merrin S Adams, and Monique T Binet, and Jennifer B Gadd, and Chris W Hickey, and Jenny L Stauber
CSIRO Land and Water, Lucas Heights, NSW 2234, Australia. Electronic address: David.spadaro@csiro.au.

The Ok Tedi mine discharges waste rock and tailings into the Ok Tedi River in Papua New Guinea. This has resulted in elevated copper concentrations throughout the Ok Tedi/Fly River system, which can potentially impact aquatic biota. Ten years of measured copper and toxicity monitoring data were used to assess the risk of chronic effects from the mine-derived copper. Cumulative probability plots of dissolved and labile copper were compared to a species sensitivity distribution (SSD) of published copper toxicity data for four regions of the river. The Cu-SSD was used to estimate the risk of chronic effects to aquatic organisms in the Ok Tedi/Fly River at a range of potential copper exposure scenarios. The risk to species at the median labile copper concentration for each region showed a gradient effect with distance downstream from the mine and only the most sensitive (0.2-11%) species were at risk. There were copper exceedances of the region-specific guideline values (GV) and default guideline value (DGV) 88% and 74% of the time, respectively, in the Ok Tedi region (closest to the mine) and this is considered a high risk of chronic effects. Measured copper concentrations in the middle Fly River, lower Fly River (farthest downstream of the mine) and the river at Kiunga (reference site) exceeded the region-specific GVs and DGVs less frequently to rarely and present a lower risk of chronic effects from copper. The risk was supported using toxicity tests with the local microalgal species Chlorella sp. Comparison of recent (2010-2020) and historical (1996-2004) copper monitoring data from the Ok Tedi/Fly River indicates a decrease in the labile copper concentrations (30-76%) at key sites from impacted regions and a subsequent decrease in risk. This coincides with improved mining practices aimed at reducing the copper load into the Ok Tedi/Fly River.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D010219 Papua New Guinea A country consisting of the eastern half of the island of New Guinea and adjacent islands, including New Britain, New Ireland, the Admiralty Islands, and New Hanover in the Bismarck Archipelago; Bougainville and Buka in the northern Solomon Islands; the D'Entrecasteaux and Trobriand Islands; Woodlark (Murua) Island; and the Louisiade Archipelago. It became independent on September 16, 1975. Formerly, the southern part was the Australian Territory of Papua, and the northern part was the UN Trust Territory of New Guinea, administered by Australia. They were administratively merged in 1949 and named Papua and New Guinea, and renamed Papua New Guinea in 1971. New Guinea, East,New Guinea, Papua
D002708 Chlorella Nonmotile unicellular green algae potentially valuable as a source of high-grade protein and B-complex vitamins. Chlorellas
D003300 Copper A heavy metal trace element with the atomic symbol Cu, atomic number 29, and atomic weight 63.55. Copper-63,Copper 63
D014874 Water Pollutants, Chemical Chemical compounds which pollute the water of rivers, streams, lakes, the sea, reservoirs, or other bodies of water. Chemical Water Pollutants,Landfill Leachate,Leachate, Landfill,Pollutants, Chemical Water
D045483 Rivers Large natural streams of FRESH WATER formed by converging tributaries and which empty into a body of water (lake or ocean). Streams,River,Stream
D018570 Risk Assessment The qualitative or quantitative estimation of the likelihood of adverse effects that may result from exposure to specified health hazards or from the absence of beneficial influences. (Last, Dictionary of Epidemiology, 1988) Assessment, Risk,Benefit-Risk Assessment,Risk Analysis,Risk-Benefit Assessment,Health Risk Assessment,Risks and Benefits,Analysis, Risk,Assessment, Benefit-Risk,Assessment, Health Risk,Assessment, Risk-Benefit,Benefit Risk Assessment,Benefit-Risk Assessments,Benefits and Risks,Health Risk Assessments,Risk Analyses,Risk Assessment, Health,Risk Assessments,Risk Benefit Assessment,Risk-Benefit Assessments

Related Publications

David A Spadaro, and Josh King, and Brad Angel, and Kitty S McKnight, and Merrin S Adams, and Monique T Binet, and Jennifer B Gadd, and Chris W Hickey, and Jenny L Stauber
July 1991, Environmental monitoring and assessment,
David A Spadaro, and Josh King, and Brad Angel, and Kitty S McKnight, and Merrin S Adams, and Monique T Binet, and Jennifer B Gadd, and Chris W Hickey, and Jenny L Stauber
June 1998, The Science of the total environment,
David A Spadaro, and Josh King, and Brad Angel, and Kitty S McKnight, and Merrin S Adams, and Monique T Binet, and Jennifer B Gadd, and Chris W Hickey, and Jenny L Stauber
May 1990, Environmental monitoring and assessment,
David A Spadaro, and Josh King, and Brad Angel, and Kitty S McKnight, and Merrin S Adams, and Monique T Binet, and Jennifer B Gadd, and Chris W Hickey, and Jenny L Stauber
January 1989, Annals of human biology,
David A Spadaro, and Josh King, and Brad Angel, and Kitty S McKnight, and Merrin S Adams, and Monique T Binet, and Jennifer B Gadd, and Chris W Hickey, and Jenny L Stauber
January 1987, Environmental pollution (Barking, Essex : 1987),
David A Spadaro, and Josh King, and Brad Angel, and Kitty S McKnight, and Merrin S Adams, and Monique T Binet, and Jennifer B Gadd, and Chris W Hickey, and Jenny L Stauber
December 1991, Papua and New Guinea medical journal,
David A Spadaro, and Josh King, and Brad Angel, and Kitty S McKnight, and Merrin S Adams, and Monique T Binet, and Jennifer B Gadd, and Chris W Hickey, and Jenny L Stauber
June 1983, Papua and New Guinea medical journal,
David A Spadaro, and Josh King, and Brad Angel, and Kitty S McKnight, and Merrin S Adams, and Monique T Binet, and Jennifer B Gadd, and Chris W Hickey, and Jenny L Stauber
March 1989, Papua and New Guinea medical journal,
David A Spadaro, and Josh King, and Brad Angel, and Kitty S McKnight, and Merrin S Adams, and Monique T Binet, and Jennifer B Gadd, and Chris W Hickey, and Jenny L Stauber
June 1989, Human biology,
David A Spadaro, and Josh King, and Brad Angel, and Kitty S McKnight, and Merrin S Adams, and Monique T Binet, and Jennifer B Gadd, and Chris W Hickey, and Jenny L Stauber
January 1992, Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene,
Copied contents to your clipboard!