A systematic review of questionnaires measuring asthma control in children in a primary care population. 2023

Sara Bousema, and Arthur M Bohnen, and Patrick J E Bindels, and Gijs Elshout
Department of General Practice, Erasmus MC, University Medical Centre Rotterdam, P.O. Box 2040, 3000 CA, Rotterdam, The Netherlands. s.bousema@erasmusmc.nl.

Several questionnaires are used to measure asthma control in children. The most appropriate tool for use in primary care is not defined. In this systematic review, we evaluated questionnaires used to measure asthma control in children in primary care and determined their usefulness in asthma management. Searches were performed in the MEDLINE, Embase, Web of Science, Google Scholar and Cochrane databases with end date 24 June 2022. The study population comprised children aged 5-18 years with asthma. Three reviewers independently screened studies and extracted data. The methodological quality of the studies was assessed, using the COSMIN criteria for the measurement properties of health status questionnaires. Studies conducted in primary care were included if a minimum of two questionnaires were compared. Studies in secondary or tertiary care and studies of quality-of-life questionnaires were excluded. Heterogeneity precluded meta-analysis. Five publications were included: four observational studies and one sub-study of a randomized controlled trial. A total of 806 children were included (aged 5-18 years). We evaluated the Asthma Control Test (ACT), childhood Asthma Control Test (c-ACT), Asthma APGAR system, NAEPP criteria and Royal College of Physicians' '3 questions' (RCP3Q). These questionnaires assess different symptoms and domains. The quality of most of the studies was rated 'intermediate' or 'poor'. The majority of the evaluated questionnaires do not show substantial agreement with one another, which makes a comparison challenging. Based on the current review, we suggest that the Asthma APGAR system seems promising as a questionnaire for determining asthma control in children in primary care.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries

Related Publications

Sara Bousema, and Arthur M Bohnen, and Patrick J E Bindels, and Gijs Elshout
December 2017, Journal of psychosomatic research,
Sara Bousema, and Arthur M Bohnen, and Patrick J E Bindels, and Gijs Elshout
February 2015, Pediatric pulmonology,
Sara Bousema, and Arthur M Bohnen, and Patrick J E Bindels, and Gijs Elshout
September 2015, Developmental medicine and child neurology,
Sara Bousema, and Arthur M Bohnen, and Patrick J E Bindels, and Gijs Elshout
December 2020, Atencion primaria,
Sara Bousema, and Arthur M Bohnen, and Patrick J E Bindels, and Gijs Elshout
January 2012, PloS one,
Sara Bousema, and Arthur M Bohnen, and Patrick J E Bindels, and Gijs Elshout
March 2018, Indian pediatrics,
Sara Bousema, and Arthur M Bohnen, and Patrick J E Bindels, and Gijs Elshout
May 2009, Arthritis and rheumatism,
Sara Bousema, and Arthur M Bohnen, and Patrick J E Bindels, and Gijs Elshout
January 2009, Research and theory for nursing practice,
Sara Bousema, and Arthur M Bohnen, and Patrick J E Bindels, and Gijs Elshout
October 2022, Journal of nursing management,
Sara Bousema, and Arthur M Bohnen, and Patrick J E Bindels, and Gijs Elshout
February 2023, Pediatric exercise science,
Copied contents to your clipboard!