The stereochemical course of the aliphatic hydroxylation of gamma-butyrobetaine by calf liver and by Pseudomonas sp AK1 gamma-butyrobetaine hydroxylases has been determined. With [3(RS)-3-3H]-gamma-butyrobetaine or [3(R)-3-3H]-gamma-butyrobetaine as substrate, a rapid and significant loss of tritium to the medium occurred. On the other hand, with [3(S)-3-3H]-gamma-butyrobetaine, only a negligible release of tritium to the aqueous medium was observed. Indeed, on hydroxylation of [3(S)-3-2H]-gamma-butyrobetaine by either the calf liver or bacterial hydroxylase, the isolated product L-carnitine was found to have retained all of the deuterium initially present in the 3(S) position. Since the absolute configuration of the product L-carnitine has been determined to be R, such results are only compatible with a hydroxylation reaction that proceeded with retention of configuration. With [methyl-14C,3(R)-3-3H]-gamma-butyrobetaine as substrate for the calf liver hydroxylase, the percentage of tritium retained in the [methyl-14C]-L-carnitine product was determined as a function of percent reaction. The results of these studies indicated that pro-R hydrogen atom abstraction exceeded 99.9%. Experiments using racemic [methyl-14C,3(RS)-3-3H]-gamma-butyrobetaine as substrate yielded similar results and additionally allowed us to estimate alpha-secondary tritium kinetic isotope effects of 1.10 and 1.31 for the bacterial and calf liver enzymes, respectively. These results are discussed within the context of the radical mechanism for gamma-butyrobetaine hydroxylase previously proposed [Blanchard, J. S., & Englard, S. (1983) Biochemistry 22, 5922], and the required topographical arrangement of enzymic oxidant and substrate is illustrated.