Misrepresentation of research citations among medical school faculty applicants. 1998

L C Goe, and A M Herrera, and W R Mower
Emergency Medicine Center, UCLA Center for the Health Sciences, USA.

OBJECTIVE A descriptive study of bibliographic misrepresentations by applicants to medical school faculty positions. METHODS The authors reviewed 250 1995 faculty applicant bibliographies from eight medical institutions, representing six medical specialities. Using computerized library database searches or direct retrieval, they evaluated the legitimacy of each journal, abstract, and book citation. The authors classified and tabulated the following discrepancies as misrepresentations: (1) citing a nonexistent article in an existent source, (2) claiming authorship on an article that did not list the applicant as an author, and (3) altering authorship order to enhance the applicant's position. RESULTS The authors found 56 misrepresented citations among 2,149 verified articles (2.6%). These misrepresentations were distributed among 39 applicants (15.6%; 95% CI, 11.5% to 20.9%); 11 of whom (4.4%) had multiple discrepancies. Sixty-eight percent of all misrepresentations were due to discrepancies in authorship order, while journal citations constituted the most frequent source of misrepresentation (77%). CONCLUSIONS Misrepresentation of bibliographic citations does exist among medical school faculty applicants. One possible solution to this problem would be to require applicants to document their bibliographic citations.

UI MeSH Term Description Entries
D007586 Job Application Process of applying for employment. It includes written application for employment or personal appearance. Employment Application,Resume, Job,Application, Employment,Application, Job,Applications, Employment,Applications, Job,Employment Applications,Job Applications,Job Resume,Job Resumes,Resumes, Job
D005180 Faculty, Medical Teaching and administrative staff having academic rank in a medical school. Faculties, Medical,Medical Faculties,Medical Faculty
D005607 Fraud Exploitation through misrepresentation of the facts or concealment of the purposes of the exploiter. Fraud, Health Care,Health Care Fraud,Kickbacks,Drug Counterfeiting,Healthcare Fraud,Counterfeiting, Drug,Fraud, Healthcare,Health Care Frauds,Kickback
D006801 Humans Members of the species Homo sapiens. Homo sapiens,Man (Taxonomy),Human,Man, Modern,Modern Man
D001319 Authorship The profession of writing. Also the identity of the writer as the creator of a literary production. Authorships
D014481 United States A country in NORTH AMERICA between CANADA and MEXICO.
D016206 Databases, Bibliographic Extensive collections, reputedly complete, of references and citations to books, articles, publications, etc., generally on a single subject or specialized subject area. Databases can operate through automated files, libraries, or computer disks. The concept should be differentiated from DATABASES, FACTUAL which is used for collections of data and facts apart from bibliographic references to them. Bibliographic Database,Bibliographic Databases,Database, Bibliographic
D028743 Professional Misconduct Violation of laws, regulations, or professional standards. Misconduct, Professional,Unprofessional Behavior,Behavior, Unprofessional,Behaviors, Unprofessional,Unprofessional Behaviors
D035843 Biomedical Research Research that involves the application of the natural sciences, especially biology and physiology, to medicine. Medical Research,Experimental Medicine,Investigational Medicine,Investigative Medicine,Research, Biomedical,Research, Medical,Medicine, Experimental,Medicine, Investigational,Medicine, Investigative

Related Publications

L C Goe, and A M Herrera, and W R Mower
August 1999, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges,
L C Goe, and A M Herrera, and W R Mower
March 1996, Annals of emergency medicine,
L C Goe, and A M Herrera, and W R Mower
September 2018, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume,
L C Goe, and A M Herrera, and W R Mower
March 2011, Anesthesia and analgesia,
L C Goe, and A M Herrera, and W R Mower
June 2013, World journal of urology,
L C Goe, and A M Herrera, and W R Mower
January 2016, Journal of neurosurgery,
L C Goe, and A M Herrera, and W R Mower
December 2010, Otolaryngology--head and neck surgery : official journal of American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery,
L C Goe, and A M Herrera, and W R Mower
December 2009, Medical teacher,
L C Goe, and A M Herrera, and W R Mower
May 2008, Clinical journal of sport medicine : official journal of the Canadian Academy of Sport Medicine,
L C Goe, and A M Herrera, and W R Mower
August 2019, American journal of surgery,
Copied contents to your clipboard!